The Grassmannian string integral (string theory)
String theory originates with the Veneziano amplitude: a formula with the physical properties of a scattering amplitude and unusually mild behavior at high energies, which turned out to describe the scattering of strings. The Veneziano amplitude has generalizations that share its appealing physical properties but correspond to no known theory of strings. These Grassmannian string amplitudes have been hard to calculate; BootLoops can evaluate them exactly and help determine whether a generalization of string theory is hiding within.
From a point on a line to points in a plane
In 1968 Gabriele Veneziano wrote down a compact formula for the scattering of four particles, the Veneziano amplitude, a ratio of Gamma functions that is also an integral over one point $x$ between $0$ and $1$:
$$A(s,t)\;=\;\frac{\Gamma(-\alpha(s))\,\Gamma(-\alpha(t))}{\Gamma(-\alpha(s)-\alpha(t))}\;=\;\int_0^1 dx\;x^{-\alpha(s)-1}\,(1-x)^{-\alpha(t)-1}, \tag{1}$$with $\alpha(s)$ and $\alpha(t)$ linear in the energy invariants $s$ and $t$ of the collision. The integrand of Eq. (1) is a product of polynomials in the integration variable raised to powers that depend on the parameters. That is the Lee–Pomeransky form in which BootLoops writes every Feynman integral, and it is equally the form of a Bayesian evidence integral (Eq. (1) is, up to normalization, the evidence of a Beta–binomial model), the class of integrals BootLoops evaluates exactly as a matter of routine.
That raises the question running through this page: which other integrals of this form, with more variables and more polynomials, still behave like scattering amplitudes, and what theory, if any, do they describe? The first generalization came within a year, when Koba and Nielsen extended Eq. (1) to $n$ particles by integrating over $n$ ordered points on the line. These integrals were later understood to be the tree amplitudesthe leading contribution to a scattering amplitude, with no closed loops of virtual particles; for a string, the contribution of the simplest worldsheet of a relativistic open string. They are also called disk integrals: the surface a string sweeps out, its worldsheet, is here a disk with the points on its rim (for a closed string, a sphere). String theory explains their main features. The poles are the masses of the string’s excited states, and each residuethe strength of a pole: the coefficient of one over the distance to the singular point is a sum over those states of products of two smaller amplitudes. Closed-string amplitudes are bilinear in open-string ones, as Kawai, Lewellen and Tye (KLT) showed in 1986, because the worldsheet carries left- and right-moving modes. And the constants in the low-energy expansion are multiple zeta values, because the amplitudes are periodsnumbers obtained by integrating rational functions with rational coefficients over regions cut out by polynomial inequalities; $\pi$, $\log 2$ and the zeta values are examples of the space of $n$ points on a line, and every such period is a multiple zeta value.
In 2019 Cachazo, Early, Guevara and Mizera (CEGM) generalized the scattering equations, whose solutions are the saddle points of such integrals, from points on a line to points in the projective spaceordinary space with points at infinity added; equivalently, its points are coordinate vectors that matter only up to an overall rescaling; the projective line is the case $k=2$ and the projective plane $k=3$ $\mathbb P^{k-1}$. Arkani-Hamed, He and Lam then wrote down the matching generalization of the Koba–Nielsen integral, the Grassmannian string integral $K(k,n)$, over the space $X(k,n)$ of $n$ points in general position in $\mathbb P^{k-1}$ modulo projective transformations. A configuration is a $k\times n$ matrix whose columns are the points; such matrices modulo row operations form the Grassmannian $\mathrm{Gr}(k,n)$, which gives the integral its name. Every $k\times k$ minorthe determinant of a square block of a matrix, here the block formed by k of its n columns of the matrix is raised to a power set by the kinematics; for $k=2$ the minors are differences $z_b-z_a$ and one recovers Koba–Nielsen. A duality identifies $X(k,n)$ with $X(n-k,n)$, so $K(3,5)$ and $K(4,6)$ are Koba–Nielsen integrals in other coordinates, while $(3,6)$ is sent to itself. The first member of the family that is not an integral over points on a line is therefore
$$K(3,6)(s)\;=\;\int_{X^+(3,6)}\omega_{3,6}\prod_{1\le a \lt b \lt c\le 6}(abc)^{\,\alpha' s_{abc}} . \tag{2}$$Here $(abc)$ is the $3\times3$ minor on columns $a,b,c$, one of twenty, which vanishes exactly when points $a$, $b$, $c$ are collinear. $X^+(3,6)$ is the positive part of the configuration space, where all ordered minors are positive, and $\omega_{3,6}$ is its canonical volume form, the product of $dx/x$ over four suitable positive coordinates $x$. Four coordinates suffice because projective transformations fix four of the six points, leaving two free points in the plane. The constant $\alpha'$ is the inverse string tension, the exponents $s_{abc}$ are CEGM’s generalized Mandelstam invariantsthe standard variables of a collision, each the square of a sum of particle momenta; the generalized ones carry three particle labels instead of two, and the $\alpha'\to0$ limit is CEGM’s generalized biadjoint amplitude $m(3,6)$. No worldsheet theory and no spectrum of states that would produce $K(3,6)$ are known.

Where the poles come from. Left: the four-point open-string amplitude integrates one point $x$ (violet) along the line between two fixed points, with a third fixed at infinity. Its poles in $s$ and in $t$ come from the two ends of the range, where the moving point meets a fixed one (orange halo). Right: $K(3,6)$ integrates two points (violet) over the plane with four held fixed (dark). Each time three of the six come into line, the minor $(abc)$ of those three vanishes and the integral develops a pole; the line is drawn in orange and the minor is named. Collinear limits of this kind give six of the sixteen families of poles; the other ten come from two points coinciding and from a pair of points merging on the line through another pair. (Animated illustration; the loops traced by the free points are arbitrary.)
An amplitude in fourteen variables
The three-label invariants $s_{abc}$ are symmetric and obey one conservation condition per label, which leaves fourteen of them independent; they are not built from any two-label quantities. One can try to force a particle interpretation by setting $s_{abc}=\tfrac12(p_a+p_b+p_c)^2$ for six massless momenta, but such combinations fill only a nine-dimensional slice of the fourteen-dimensional kinematic space; the other five directions cannot be written in terms of six momenta in any spacetime dimension. So $K(3,6)$ is not the S-matrix element of six particles, and the question of its unitaritythe requirement that the probabilities of all possible outcomes add up to one; for amplitudes it requires the residue at each pole to be a sum over the physical states exchanged there does not arise.
The integral nevertheless has the analytic form of an amplitude: it is meromorphicanalytic except for poles: near each singular point the function blows up like one over a power of the distance, with no branch cuts in the fourteen invariants, and its only singularities are simple poles on sixteen families of evenly spaced parallel hyperplanes $\alpha'\kappa_a(s)=-n$, $n=0,1,2,\dots$, where each $\kappa_a$ is a fixed linear combination of the invariants. This is the Veneziano pole structure in more variables, and the high-energy behavior is also that of a string amplitude. The properties asked of a tree-level S-matrix element can each be transcribed to three-label kinematics, and one can then determine which of them $K(3,6)$ has. Where string theory derives a property from the worldsheet or the spectrum, the question is what structure of the integral accounts for it instead.

The four-point open-string amplitude $K(2,4)=\Gamma(\varepsilon s)\Gamma(\varepsilon t)/\Gamma(\varepsilon s+\varepsilon t)$ against $\varepsilon s$ at fixed $\varepsilon t=\tfrac12$, with $\varepsilon$ standing for $\alpha'$. Its only singularities are simple poles at the evenly spaced points $\varepsilon s=0,-1,-2,\dots$ (dashed lines), one for each mass level of the string. $K(3,6)$ has the same structure in fourteen variables, with simple poles on sixteen families of evenly spaced hyperplanes as its only singularities. (Drawn from Eq. (18) of the paper.)
Factorization without clustering
In quantum field theory a pole of a tree amplitude comes from a particle going on shellobeying the relation between energy, momentum and mass that a real, detectable particle satisfies, and the residue is $\sum_{\rm states}A_L(I,P)\,A_R(-P,\bar I)$. That is a product of two smaller amplitudes, with the external labels split into a set $I$ and its complement $\bar I$, summed over the states of the exchanged particle of momentum $P$. In The Quantum Theory of Fields Weinberg derives this from two hypotheses: the sum over states comes from unitarity, and the split into two groups from cluster decomposition, the principle that distant experiments do not affect each other.
The sixteen families of poles of $K(3,6)$ correspond to the sixteen facetsthe faces of a polytope of one dimension less than the polytope itself: a cube has square facets, and a four-dimensional polytope has three-dimensional ones of a four-dimensional polytope $P(3,6)$ determined by the integrand. Each facet is a way for six points to degenerate: three become collinear (six facets), two coincide (six), or a pair of points merges on the line through another pair (four). Arkani-Hamed, He and Lam had shown that the leading residue at a facet is an integral of the same class, which for $k\ge3$ need not split in two. With that and a further result they obtained with Thomas, all sixteen leading residues can be identified with known functions. Where three points are collinear, the residue is the six-point Koba–Nielsen integral on the line through them. Where two points coincide, it is a six-point disk integral with one channel removed, summed over two orderings. At the four remaining facets it is a product of three Beta functions, three Veneziano amplitudes with no variable in common. The Beta-function identification and two of the six collinear ones hold in closed form at every order in $\alpha'$; the rest are exact at leading order and checked numerically beyond it.

The three ways six points in the plane can degenerate (top, degenerate points in orange) and the facet of the polytope $P(3,6)$ that each produces (below); the sixteen facets are the sixteen families of poles of $K(3,6)$. Where three points fall on a line the facet is the associahedron $K_5$, the polytope of the six-point open string, and the residue is the Koba–Nielsen integral $K(2,6)$ on that line. Where two points coincide it is $K_5$ with one edge (orange, left) shrunk to a vertex (orange, middle), and the residue is a six-point disk integral with one channel absent, summed over two orderings. Where a pair of points merges on the line through another pair it is a cube; each pair of opposite faces is cut out by two channels and gives one Veneziano factor, so the residue is a product of three Beta functions. None of the three is a product of two polytopes attached to complementary sets of labels, the shape that cluster decomposition would require. (Redrawn from Figure 1 of the paper.)
At every level $n$ of every family of poles the residue is again built from amplitudes of the degenerate configuration. It is a theorem that
$$\operatorname{Res}_{\alpha'\kappa_a=-n}K(3,6)\;=\;\sum_{\lambda}V^{(n)}_\lambda(s)\,F_\lambda(s_\parallel) ,$$a finite sum over an index $\lambda$. The $V^{(n)}_\lambda$ are polynomials of degree at most $n$ in the invariants. The $F_\lambda$ are the string integrals attached to the facet with exponents shifted by integers, and depend only on the kinematics $s_\parallel$ of the degenerate configuration. In words, $K(3,6)$ factorizes onto its boundary at every pole and every level, and the proof assumes nothing about a spectrum of states.
The same derivation applies word for word to the open string. There, however, the facet at a channel is a product of two smaller associahedra, one for each side, so every $F_\lambda$ is a product $A_LA_R$ of two disk integrals in separate variables. Cluster decomposition shows up inside the integral as that product structure. For $K(3,6)$ no facet is a product of two polytopes attached to complementary subsets of the labels; the cubes are products, but of three factors. Cluster decomposition presupposes a split into two subsystems exchanging one momentum, with one invariant $s_I=s_{\bar I}$ for the split. In three-label kinematics a pair of labels has no invariant, and complementary triples have different ones, $s_{156}\ne s_{234}$. Cluster decomposition therefore cannot be formulated for $K(3,6)$, so it is neither obeyed nor violated, and Weinberg positivity is likewise undefined, since it is a statement about elastic residues, in which an amplitude is paired with its own conjugate.
On the nine-dimensional slice where the invariants do come from six momenta, the pole hyperplanes $s_{156}=0$ and $s_{234}=0$ coincide and the three-particle poles become double. The double-pole coefficient is exactly a product of two four-point disk amplitudes. Read as a function of six momenta, then, $K(3,6)$ is not a tree-level S-matrix element, if only because its three-particle propagators appear squared.
The double copy and the KLT kernel
The KLT relations, which make each closed-string amplitude a double copy of open-string ones, have a second derivation that does not use a worldsheet. They are the twisted period relations of Cho and Matsumoto for the space of points on a line. The KLT kernel, the matrix of coefficients in the bilinear, is the inverse of the intersection matrixa square table of numbers recording how the real integration regions meet one another, with the phases of the multivalued integrand taken into account of the real integration regions, as Mizera showed. Those relations need only a space and a multivalued function on it. In every earlier example of a double copy, though, the worldsheet argument was also available, so one could not tell whether the double copy needs the worldsheet.
For six points in the plane the space $X(3,6)$ and the multivalued integrand on it are both available, and no worldsheet is known. The real configurations with all twenty minors nonzero fall into $372$ regions, the generalized color orderings of Cachazo, Early and Zhang, sixty of them convex. Integrals over these regions play the part of the color-ordered open-string amplitudes, the disk integrals with the points in different orders along the rim; $K(3,6)$ itself is the integral over the positive region against its own canonical form. The intersection form of the sixty convex regions can be written in closed form, as a combinatorial rule called the face rule. At one rational kinematic point a numerical computation finds that this form has rank exactly twenty-six at finite $\alpha'$ and that the period relations hold as functions of $\alpha'$. The inverse of the form on any twenty-six independent regions is then a KLT kernel exact in $\alpha'$, and the bilinear built with it is the analog of the closed-string amplitude. At the same point, through sixth order in $\alpha'$, the expansion of this bilinear is the single-valued image of the expansion of $K(3,6)$: $\zeta(2k)\to0$ and $\zeta(2k+1)\to2\zeta(2k+1)$. The same map takes the disk amplitude of the open string to the sphere amplitude of the closed string. The face rule at general kinematics is a conjecture; the checks are at that one kinematic point, plus a sign check at a second.
The space of seven points on a line is also four-dimensional with fourteen invariants, so one must check that $X(3,6)$ is not that space in other coordinates. One can prove that $K(3,6)$ is not a combination of seven-point disk or sphere integrals with constant coefficients under any linear map of the kinematics. Two invariants of the spaces already differ: the Euler characteristica whole number attached to a shape: vertices minus edges plus faces, and so on with alternating signs; unchanged when the shape is continuously deformed, $26$ against $24$, and the count of points over a finite field, which for $X(3,6)$ has an irreducible quadratic factor.
The low-energy expansion and its zeta values
The low-energy expansion of a string tree amplitude has coefficients that are multiple zeta values, the nested sums $\zeta(n_1,\ldots,n_r)=\sum_{m_1\gt\cdots\gt m_r\ge1}m_1^{-n_1}\cdots m_r^{-n_r}$ (with $n_1\ge2$ so the sum converges), with weight $n_1+\cdots+n_r$ set by the order in $\alpha'$. The theorem that guarantees this is about points on a line; the classical periods of six points in a plane are different numbers, related to K3 surfaces. So there was no general reason to expect multiple zeta values from $K(3,6)$, and Arkani-Hamed, He and Lam had asked which integrands give multiple zeta values only. As far as the author knows, no expansion of any $K(k,n)$ with $k\ge3$ had been carried past leading order. Writing $K(3,6)=\sum_{w\ge0}\alpha'^{\,w-4}c_w(s)$, one finds, exactly in the fourteen invariants,
$$c_2=q_2\,\zeta(2),\quad c_3=q_3\,\zeta(3),\quad c_4=q_4\,\zeta(4),\quad c_5=Q_5\,\zeta(5)+R_5\,\zeta(2)\zeta(3),\quad c_6=A\,\pi^6+B\,\zeta(3)^2 , \tag{3}$$with $c_0=m(3,6)$, $c_1=0$, and $q_2,\dots,B$ rational functions with simple poles on the sixteen hyperplanes $\kappa_a=0$ and nowhere else (the weight-six pair $A$, $B$ was determined from values of $c_6$ at rational kinematic points). The integration region is cut into fifty-two cones, and the individual cone integrals contain constants that are not zeta values, such as polylogarithmsgeneralizations of the logarithm defined by power series; their values at special numbers are the typical constants of such expansions at roots of unity; these constants cancel only in the sum over cones. The cancellation takes place across every internal wall between two adjacent cones: the two integrals over $0\lt y\lt1$ in the transverse variable combine by $y\to1/y$ into one over $0\lt y\lt\infty$. That integral is a Beta function, the four-point string amplitude, whose expansion contains single zeta values only, so the unwanted constants cancel wall by wall. Independently, a theorem that rests on results of Brown and Panzer establishes that the coefficients are multiple zeta values of weight at most $w$ at every order. The theorem needs only one property of the positive coordinates: integrating the variables out one at a time, in a suitable order, keeps every singularity linear in those that remain. That the weight is exactly $w$ remains a conjecture.
Through weight seven every multiple zeta value is a polynomial in ordinary $\zeta(n)$, so weight eight is the first order at which the coefficients of $K(3,6)$ could contain anything else. At weight eight there is one element, $\zeta(3,5)$, believed not to be such a polynomial. Numerical evaluation at two unrelated rational kinematic points finds that $c_7$ and $c_8$ are polynomials in single zeta values, with zero coefficient of $\zeta(3,5)$. As a control, when the same integrand is integrated at one of those points over the same region against a different logarithmic form, $\zeta(3,5)$ appears with coefficient $-483731/29160$. In amplitude language the form is the color ordering, so which constants appear depends on the ordering as well as on the space, a pattern Schlotterer and Stieberger found in ordinary disk integrals. The author conjectures that a region integrated against its own canonical form, as in $K(3,6)$, never produces $\zeta(3,5)$. The evidence so far is two kinematic points and one comparison form, and a single kinematic point at which $K(3,6)$ requires $\zeta(3,5)$ would refute the conjecture.

The weight-eight coefficient $c_8$ at the base kinematic point $s_0$, decomposed on the weight-eight basis $\zeta(8)$, $\zeta(3)\zeta(5)$, $\zeta(2)\zeta(3)^2$ and $\zeta(3,5)$, with $\zeta(3,5)$ on its own scale in the right panel. Violet: $K(3,6)$ itself, with rational coefficients (identified numerically from about sixty digits) $-\tfrac{7173761239}{83980800}$, $\tfrac{11628931}{145800}$, $-\tfrac{74762681}{437400}$ and $0$. Orange: the comparison integral over the same region with the same Koba–Nielsen factor and kinematics and a different logarithmic form $\omega'$, whose $\zeta(3,5)$ coefficient is $-\tfrac{483731}{29160}\approx-16.6$. So integrals on this space can produce $\zeta(3,5)$, and the expansion of $K(3,6)$ does not contain it at the points computed. (Drawn from Table 2 and Eqs. (98) and (101) of the paper.)
Summary of main results
Three properties that string theory explains through the worldsheet hold for $K(3,6)$, the first Grassmannian string integral that is not an integral over points on a line, with no worldsheet in sight.
- Factorization onto boundaries. At every one of the sixteen families of poles, and at every level $n$, the residue of $K(3,6)$ is a finite sum of polynomials in the invariants times integer-shifted string integrals of the degenerate configuration (Proposition 1, proven). Each residue is thus an amplitude of the boundary, as for the string. What is missing at generic kinematics is the further split of that residue into two smaller amplitudes summed over intermediate states; that split is traced to cluster decomposition, which needs a two-body subsystem carrying one invariant, and three-label kinematics has neither.
- The double copy without a worldsheet. Integrals of the same integrand over the $372$ real regions of $X(3,6)$ play the part of color-ordered open-string amplitudes, spanning a space of dimension $26$ rather than $(n-3)!$, and the integral over complex configurations plays the part of the closed string. The two are related by a KLT-type bilinear whose kernel is the inverse intersection form of the regions, given in closed form for the sixty convex regions by the face rule. The relations are checked exactly at rational kinematics, and $K(3,6)$ is proven not to be a combination of seven-point disk or sphere integrals with constant coefficients.
- Zeta values to all orders. The low-energy coefficients are multiple zeta values at every order in $\alpha'$ (Theorem 3, resting on theorems of Brown and Panzer), although the classical periods of six points in a plane are K3 periods and nothing general required it. Closed forms are obtained through weight five, Eq. (3) above, the weight-six functions $A$ and $B$ are determined from exact values, and through weight eight only ordinary $\zeta(n)$ appear: the one genuinely multiple zeta value that could enter, $\zeta(3,5)$, has coefficient zero at two unrelated kinematic points, while a control integral on the same space with a different form produces it.
- An S-matrix checklist in fourteen variables. Ten standard properties of scattering amplitudes are transcribed to three-label kinematics and assigned a status for $K(3,6)$, from theorem to conjecture to not applicable: meromorphy with simple poles on sixteen families of hyperplanes, Regge growth and exponential softness at high energy, a unique saddle point in the positive region, double three-particle poles with leading coefficient $A_4A_4$ on the slice where the invariants come from six momenta, and positivity of the closed-string analog.
Whether some two-dimensional worldsheet theory produces these integrals, the question that would make them a string theory, remains open; a presentation with eight or more points and kinematic prefactors is not excluded by anything proved here.
The paper
- Factorization without clustering and the six-point Grassmannian string integral (PDF) — Matthew D. Schwartz. A preliminary version of the paper.
Supplementary material
- Supplementary material (PDF) — the full account of the computations summarized in Appendix B of the paper: the kinematic points, the conventions and values of each comparison, and the inputs and heights of the integer-relation searches.
- cegm-x36.zip (14 files, 1.3 MB) — the companion package for $K(3,6)$: a README, the proof records behind Appendix A (the weight-3/4 cancellation theorem and the weight-five structure theorem with the exact fractions $Q_5$, $R_5$), the weight-six data record (the exact functions $A(s)$ and $B(s)$, the 190 kinematic points on which they were determined and 90 further test points, with its own check script), and
cegm-verify.py, one Python file (standard library plus mpmath) that pins the data files by SHA-256 and recomputes every closed form the package documents. Code under the MIT License, data and text under CC BY 4.0. - kn-evaluator-2-2026-09-02-r6.tar.gz (README) — kn-evaluator 2, the general tool used for the open-string comparisons: it evaluates color-ordered open-string tree amplitudes at finite tension with a rigorous error statement, among them the six-point disk integrals $K(2,6)$ that appear as residues of $K(3,6)$.
References
| G. Veneziano, Construction of a crossing-symmetric, Regge-behaved amplitude for linearly rising trajectories, Nuovo Cim. A 57 (1968) 190 | the four-point amplitude that began string theory, $K(2,4)$ in the paper’s notation |
| Z. Koba and H. B. Nielsen, Reaction amplitude for $n$ mesons: a generalization of the Veneziano–Bardakçı–Ruegg–Virasoro model, Nucl. Phys. B 10 (1969) 633 | the $n$-point integral over ordered points on a line, $K(2,n)$ |
| S. Weinberg, The Quantum Theory of Fields, Vol. 1: Foundations, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1995) | derives the factorized form of residues from unitarity and cluster decomposition |
| H. Kawai, D. C. Lewellen and S. H. H. Tye, A relation between tree amplitudes of closed and open strings, Nucl. Phys. B 269 (1986) 1 | closed-string tree amplitudes as bilinears in open-string ones (KLT) |
| F. Cachazo, N. Early, A. Guevara and S. Mizera, Scattering equations: from projective spaces to tropical Grassmannians, JHEP 06 (2019) 039 | scattering equations and Mandelstam invariants for points in $\mathbb P^{k-1}$; the amplitude $m(3,6)$ |
| N. Arkani-Hamed, S. He and T. Lam, Stringy canonical forms, JHEP 02 (2021) 069 | defined the Grassmannian string integrals $K(k,n)$ and found their leading residues at facets |
| N. Arkani-Hamed, S. He, T. Lam and H. Thomas, Binary geometries, generalized particles and strings, and cluster algebras, Phys. Rev. D 107 (2023) 066015 | identified the facet integrals of the $D_4$ cluster string integral, the further result used to name the sixteen residues |
| K. Cho and K. Matsumoto, Intersection theory for twisted cohomologies and twisted Riemann’s period relations I, Nagoya Math. J. 139 (1995) 67 | the twisted period relations that, in Mizera’s formulation, reproduce KLT with no worldsheet |
| S. Mizera, Inverse of the string theory KLT kernel, JHEP 06 (2017) 084 | the KLT kernel as the inverse intersection matrix of the real integration regions |
| F. Cachazo, N. Early and Y. Zhang, Color-dressed generalized biadjoint scalar amplitudes: local planarity, SIGMA 20 (2024) 016 | the generalized color orderings, $372$ real regions for six points in the plane |
| O. Schlotterer and S. Stieberger, Motivic multiple zeta values and superstring amplitudes, J. Phys. A 46 (2013) 475401 | the motivic organization of disk integrals with which the paper’s ordering pattern agrees |
| F. Brown, The massless higher-loop two-point function, Commun. Math. Phys. 287 (2009) 925 | the linear-reducibility criterion on which the all-orders zeta-value theorem rests |
| E. Panzer, Algorithms for the symbolic integration of hyperlogarithms with applications to Feynman integrals, Comput. Phys. Commun. 188 (2015) 148 | hyperlogarithm integration, the other input to that theorem |