Demography of sunspots (solar physics)

A sunspot group lives for days to weeks, but the Sun's rotation hides most of each life. What kills sunspots has stayed unsettled for 150 years. Survival analysis, the statistics of partly observed lifespans used in medicine, shows that sunspot groups age while spot regions on other stars do not. Includes a short film.

The aging of sunspots — and starspot regions that die without aging — the story of this page told in six minutes: how a century and a half of daily sunspot records, read with the survival statistics of medicine and demography, show that individual sunspot groups appear to age while the spot regions tracked on five hundred other stars do not.

Las manchas solares envejecen, y las regiones de manchas estelares mueren sin envejecer — en español: the same film narrated and lettered in Spanish, seven minutes.

A registry of broken life histories

A sunspot is a place where the Sun’s magnetic field has gathered into a bundle strong enough to choke off the convection beneath it, so the patch runs cooler than its surroundings and looks dark; spots emerge in groups. The Royal Greenwich Observatory began logging every group visible on the disk on May 9, 1874, one line per group per day with its position and area, and the USAF/NOAA network has kept the log since 1977. Through 2024 the combined log holds 256,205 daily records.

Thirteen days of the Sun in white light, May 1–14, 2024, one frame every four hours. Rotation carries each group from the eastern (left) limb to the western limb in about two weeks; the large southern group, NOAA 13664, comes around the limb small, grows into the biggest group of the current cycle as it crosses, and is carried out of view still alive. (Images: NASA/SDO and the HMI science team.)

What kills a group has been argued over for most of a century: erosion by the surrounding convection (Simon and Leighton, 1964), decay at a rate set by present size (the tradition of Gnevyshev, 1938, and Waldmeier, 1955), or a clock wound at birth. The second tradition implies a lifetime $\tau$ proportional to the group’s peak area $A_{\max}$, $\tau = \alpha A_{\max}$, and even that empirical law is unsettled: three ways of measuring the constant $\alpha$ disagree by a factor of four or more.

The disagreement over $\alpha$ traces to the Sun’s rotation. Seen from Earth the Sun turns once in about 27 days, so a group is measurable for at most about nine days before rotation carries it over the western limbthe edge of the Sun’s visible disk; rotation carries a group into view at the eastern limb and out of view at the western limb. It then spends roughly two weeks hidden on the far side, and a survivor returns over the eastern limb, where observers have almost always logged it as a new group. The registry therefore holds a great many interrupted life histories (figure below): of the 25,883 groups followed from birth, 16,551 were seen to die on the disk, but 9,325, more than a third, reached the limb alive. Earlier lifetime studies each handled the hidden stretches differently, some keeping only groups whose whole history was seen on the disk and others filling in each far-side passage by assumption.

A schematic of the Sun seen from above its pole. The lower half of a circle, shaded cream and ringed with filled black dots, is labeled facing Earth, about 9 usable days; the upper half, hatched gray and ringed with open dots, is labeled far side, unobserved, about 14 days. East limb and west limb are marked at the two ends of the dividing line, a curved arrow beside the circle shows the sense of rotation, and a small open circle below it, labeled Earth, marks the observer’s direction. Underneath, a row of dots runs left to right as a timeline: filled dots from day 0, first seen, to day 9, west limb, then a hatched gray bar, then open dots from day 23, east limb, logged as new.

Why so many life histories in the registry are interrupted. Seen from above the Sun’s pole, rotation carries a group across the half of the Sun that faces Earth, where it can be measured for about nine days (filled dots), and then around the far side, where it is hidden for about two weeks (open dots on the hatched half). A group that survives the passage comes back over the eastern limb, and the registry logs it there as a new group. The row of dots underneath reads the same circuit as a timeline: a record that stops at day 9 says only that the group was still alive when it left. (Adapted from Figure 1c of the sunspot paper; a schematic, no data.)

Reading the registry as a life table

Survival analysis, developed in medicine and demography, was built for interrupted records of lives: in a clinical trial some patients are still alive when the study ends. Its central object is the hazardthe risk of dying per unit time at a given age, among those still alive at that age; for a sunspot group, the probability that a group alive today is gone tomorrow, the risk of dying per unit time at each age among those still alive; a physicist would call it an age-dependent decay rate. To fit a model of the hazard, one writes down the probability of exactly what was seen. A record that ends with the subject alive is censoreda life history that stops while the subject still exists, because observation ended; it fixes only a lower limit on the lifetime and contributes the probability $S(L)$ of surviving at least to its last day $L$; a death known only to lie between days $L$ and $R$ contributes $S(L) - S(R)$. Turnbull showed in 1976 how to extract a survival curve $S$ of any shape from records of this kind; read age by age, that curve is the life tablethe demographer’s table of a population by age: how many are still alive at each age and what fraction of them die before the next.

The sunspot registry can be read the same way. Threading the daily records into individual lives gives 42,578 life-history segments, 25,883 of them born in view. Under one convention, every life not seen to end is censored at its last sighting before the western limb. Under a second, eastern reappearances are matched to western exits with the rotation law that Newton and Nunn measured in 1951, and an unmatched exit is coded as a death somewhere in the hidden interval. Where several exits and returns could be paired in more than one way, a third treatment sums the likelihood over every allowed assignment: 13.9 million of them are enumerated one by one, and where the exits and returns are too entangled for that, the sum is done exactly by a different algorithm or, in the very largest cases, by a calibrated approximation.

One more ingredient comes from demography: individuals differ in hardiness that no record captures. In 1979 Vaupel, Manton and Stallard gave that hidden hardiness a name, frailtya fixed, unobserved multiplier on an individual’s risk of death, drawn once at birth; frail individuals carry a large multiplier and tend to die first, and a form: a fixed multiplier on each individual’s hazard, drawn once at birth. Because the frail die first, a population’s death rate can level off or fall while every member’s own risk climbs. From the 1990s debates over mortality plateaus in Mediterranean fruit-fly cohorts and among the oldest humans, demographers concluded that a flattening population rate is consistent with individuals who keep aging.

Sunspot groups grow old

At first sight the life table built from the registry shows the opposite of aging. After an infant mortality of 0.29 per day on the first day, the population’s daily hazard holds near 0.12 to 0.14 through ages two to seven days and then falls (the points in the figure below). To recover each group’s own risk, the fit has to condition on something observable that tells one group from another, and the registry records such a quantity for every group on every day, namely its area. The baseline model gives group $i$, at age $a$ days, the hazard

$$h_i(a) \;=\; z_i \,\exp\!\big[\,\beta_0 + \beta_1 \log\big(A_i(a)+1\big) + B\,a\,\big].$$

Here $A_i(a)$ is the group’s recorded area that day, in millionths of the solar hemisphere; $z_i$ is its frailty, drawn at birth from a gamma distributiona standard family of skewed distributions for positive quantities; the usual choice for frailty because the population’s death rate then has an exact formula with mean one and fixed for life; $\beta_0$ sets the level and $\beta_1$ the dependence on size; and $B$ is the age slope. Every memoryless account of spot death, in which a group’s fate depends only on its present state, predicts exactly $B = 0$ once area and frailty are held fixed.

In the fit the hazard scales as $(A+1)^{-1.15}$, which makes present area the strongest single driver of death: bigger groups are far safer. The fitted age slope is $B = +0.184 \pm 0.008$ per day in log hazard. Since $e^{0.184} \approx 1.20$, a group’s risk of dying rises about twenty percent per day in the baseline model, at fixed size and fixed hardiness. Dropping the age term worsens the fit by 601.5 units of AIC, the penalized fit score used to rank the models, where a difference of 10 counts as decisive. The frailty is needed too: leave it out and the fitted slope turns negative, because the early deaths of the frail groups hide the rise in each group’s own risk. Under the fitted gamma form, groups at the 10th and 90th percentiles of frailty, identical in area and age, differ thirty-fold in risk.

Daily death hazard on a logarithmic vertical axis from about 0.003 to 1 per day against age since first observation from 0 to 10 days. Black filled circles labeled measured start near 0.29 at age 0, sit near 0.12 to 0.14 from ages 2 to 8, and drop at ages 9 and 10 with large error bars. A solid orange curve labeled population, fitted, falls smoothly from about 0.3 to about 0.06. Three dashed orange straight lines rise gently from left to right: the top one labeled frail individual, z = 2.8, runs near 0.7 to 1; the middle one labeled average, z = 0.39, from about 0.17 to 0.45; the bottom one labeled hardy individual, z = 0.0077, from about 0.004 to 0.012.

How a population can look ageless while every member ages. Black points: the registry’s measured daily death rate at each age, with 95% intervals, counting every record that ends at the limb as alive at last sight. Dashed lines: the risk of a single group in a fitted model with hardiness and age alone, drawn for a frail, an average and a hardy group (the 90th, 50th and 10th percentiles of the frailty distribution); each rises with age. Solid curve: the same model’s death rate for the whole population, which falls with age as the points do, because the frail groups die in the first days and leave the hardy ones behind. The curve runs below the points at ages 3 to 8, a shortfall of this simple parametric form that the paper notes. (Panel a of Figure 2 of the sunspot paper.)

The age slope $B$ stays positive under every form of the area dependence, every frailty distribution and both far-side conventions that were fitted, although its size ranges from +0.042 to +0.247 per day across those choices. The age term also shows up in an independent catalog from the Debrecen Observatory in Hungary. One observational effect could fake aging: a group that the observers lose while it is still alive goes into the registry as a death, and because groups shrink before they die, such false deaths fall late in life. Simulated populations with no aging, with sightings removed at the loss rate measured for the observing network, give fitted slopes nowhere near the measured one. The decay laws from the literature, each turned into a law for the risk of death by way of three explicit bridging assumptions, all fail against the registry data. Rejecting a law in the particular form tested does not necessarily rule out the physical mechanism behind it. The authors present the study as a measurement of what the catalogs contain and make no claim that any earlier lifetime study is wrong.

The aging rate over the solar cycle

The Sun’s spot production rises and falls in a cycle of about eleven years, and near each maximum the magnetic field at the Sun’s poles changes sign. The aging rate turns out to follow this cycle, in an analysis added after the study’s original plan had been set: the age slope is enhanced inside a window that opens near each cycle maximum, as the polar field reverses (figure below). The enhancement has amplitude $k = 0.210 \pm 0.034$ per day, more than doubling the slope at maximum, and fades with an e-folding timethe time over which a decaying quantity falls by a factor of e, about 2.7; after two e-folding times about a seventh is left of 2.25 ± 0.42 years, about as fast as the sunspot number itself declines after each maximum.

Enhancement of the log-hazard age slope, in inverse days from minus 0.15 to 0.35, against calendar year from 1954 to 2026. Seven gray vertical bands mark the windows of solar cycles 19 through 25, each labeled with its cycle number at the bottom; small orange triangles at the top edge mark the polar-field reversal epochs and dotted gray vertical lines mark the cycle maxima, with the words reversal and maximum written beside the first ones. A thick orange curve, the fitted window profile, is zero between cycles and, from each cycle maximum, rises and then decays back toward zero through the window; annotations give amplitude k = 0.210 plus or minus 0.034 and e-folding time tau = 2.25 plus or minus 0.42 yr. Short dashed orange horizontal segments show the profile averaged over each window. Black filled circles with vertical error bars and horizontal extent bars, labeled fitted amplitude plus or minus s.e., give each cycle's measured enhancement: about 0.05 for cycle 19, about minus 0.10 for cycle 20, about 0.07 for cycle 21, about 0.00 for cycle 22, about 0.14 for cycle 23; cycle 24 is drawn as an open circle near 0.15; a small gold triangle near 0.10 in cycle 23 is labeled Kislovodsk catalog, cycle 23; a gold open diamond with a large error bar near 0.05 at 2024 is labeled cycle 25, partial window.

Cycle-by-cycle enhancement of the aging rate. For each cycle since 1954 the point is the fitted increase in the age slope inside that cycle’s window (gray band, opening at the polar-field reversal and closing at the next minimum), and the orange curve is the shared profile fitted to all of them: a jump near maximum that decays over about two years. The amplitude differs from cycle to cycle; cycle 20 is negative, cycle 24 (open) depends on the estimator, an independent catalog confirms cycle 23 (gold triangle), and cycle 25’s window had only begun (gold diamond). Aging runs faster for a couple of years after each cycle maximum, by an amount that varies between cycles. (Figure 6 of the sunspot paper.)

The enhancement differs in size from one cycle to the next. For cycle 20 it is negative under every estimator tried; for cycle 24 it depends on the estimator, and on an independent catalog from the Kislovodsk mountain station in the Caucasus it comes out mildly negative, although that same catalog reproduces the cycle 23 enhancement at seven to nine standard deviations. Because the form of the window was revised once after cycle 25 had begun, cycle 26 will be the first cycle to test the profile without having had any part in shaping it.

The eroding root

If a group’s risk rises with age while its visible state is held fixed, then something inside the group that the registry does not record must be changing as it gets older. Six published mechanisms, seventeen new aging mechanisms, and roughly fifty candidates for what drives or carries the cycle modulation were written out and tested, and the data establish none of them. One of the aging mechanisms is not eliminated and can be developed as a physical hypothesis, consistent with the measured law but not established by it: a group dies when turbulent erosion thins its subsurface magnetic root past a breaking point.

The eroding-root hypothesis, drawn rather than simulated. The group’s magnetic bundle is anchored deep in the convection zone and turbulent eddies steadily wear the anchor thin; the bar at right tracks what is left of it. The group dies the first time an eddy is stronger than what remains, and its spots fade from the surface. (From the film above.)

In the eroding-root picture a group is the visible top of a bundle of magnetic fluxthe amount of magnetic field threading a surface, roughly field strength times area; a sunspot group marks where a flux bundle breaks the Sun’s surface, most of it below the surface, held at some anchoring depth by magnetic tensionthe force along curved magnetic field lines that acts to straighten them, like the tension in a stretched string. Let $M$ be the margin: the flux anchored there in excess of the minimum needed to hold the bundle, equal to $M_0$ at emergence. Suppose eddies at that depth strip flux away steadily, so that $M(a) = M_0 - c\,a$. Suppose further that rarer, stronger blows arrive at random at a rate $\nu$, with strengths $\Phi$ exponentially distributed about a mean $\Phi_*$. The group dies at the first blow stronger than the margin that remains, so its hazard at fixed area is the rate of such blows (with $M_{0,i}$ the margin group $i$ is born with):

$$h_i(a) \;=\; \nu\,\Pr\big[\Phi \gt M(a)\big] \;=\; \nu\, e^{-M(a)/\Phi_*} \;=\; \nu\, e^{-M_{0,i}/\Phi_*}\, e^{B a}, \qquad B = \frac{c}{\Phi_*}.$$

The risk rises exactly exponentially with age while margin remains, which is the factor $e^{Ba}$ found in the fits to the registry, and the prefactor $e^{-M_{0,i}/\Phi_*}$ plays the part of the frailty $z_i$: groups born with thin margins die first. The construction is borrowed from the Strehler–Mildvan theory of mortality (1960), and the exponential rise it produces is Gompertz’s 1825 law of human mortality. If the steady erosion removes about one blow’s worth of flux per convective turnover time $\tau_c$, then $B \approx 1/\tau_c$. A mixing-length estimate low in the convection zone gives $\tau_c \approx 3.5$ days, or $1/\tau_c \approx 0.29$ per day, the order of the fitted slopes, though that figure rests on the fastest of several turnover-time conventions, which differ among themselves by a factor of three to five. The layers just below the surface, by contrast, overturn in hours, far too fast to match the fitted slope. The cycle modulation would then mean that the root is somehow coupled to the Sun’s global field; what would do the coupling is not identified.

Equating the fitted rate with a turnover rate at some anchoring depth is an assumption, and the depth itself is not measured. Taken literally, the eroding-root hazard form also fits worse than the best unconstrained hazard shape, by more than the decisive margin; under each far-side convention the misfit comes from a single restriction built into the premise, and once that restriction is relaxed the form agrees. The hypothesis can be tested with observations that exist or are planned. Far-side imaging can follow groups past the limb, and helioseismic imaging beneath groups of known age can compare their roots: if roots erode, the older of two groups of equal area should look weaker below the surface. Solar Orbiter’s high-latitude passes begin in 2029, early enough to cover cycle 26’s polar-field reversals, which mark when that cycle’s window of faster aging should open.

On other stars, spot regions die without aging

On other stars, outside a handful with Doppler or transit maps, a dark region appears only as a small dip in brightness that recurs once per rotation until the region is gone. Such a dip, followed from one rotation to the next in a star’s light curve (its brightness record), is called a spot feature; most likely each one is several spots or groups blended at one longitude. The sample is 509 heavily spotted dwarfs observed by the Kepler and TESS space telescopes: Sun-like G and K stars, cooler and smaller early-M dwarfs, and 37 stars past the fully convective boundary, the mass below which a star has no radiative corea star’s inner region where energy moves outward as radiation through gas that does not churn; the Sun has one, the smallest stars do not and convects throughout. On these stars 10,051 features were tracked from birth to death; roughly 6,500 of them, on 260 stars, enter the fits. The likelihood is the same censored kind used for the Sun, with dip depth at birth in place of area and one frailty per star.

Starspot features give the opposite result from sunspot groups: within a single star, at fixed birth depth, a feature in its tenth rotation is at the same risk of dying as one in its third. On the G–K dwarfs the fitted age slope is 0.0056 per rotation, consistent with no aging, and simulations with injected aging show that a slope of 0.05 per rotation would have been detected; the solar aging rate, converted to these stars’ rotations, would be about 35 times that detection bound. On the early-M dwarfs the corresponding bound, 0.12 per rotation, is less secure. Median lifetimes come out at four to seven rotations depending on the sample and the estimator, with the caveat that the tracking cannot follow a feature much beyond six or seven rotations. Within the range it can follow, the star’s rotation sets the lifetime. Across 438 Kepler stars the median lifetime $L$, in days, depends on the rotation period $P$, in days, alone:

$$L \;=\; 10^{0.868}\,P^{\,0.828}\ \text{days}.$$

The exponent’s 95% interval runs from 0.767 to 0.887 (figure below). Activity on cool stars is usually organized by the Rossby numberthe rotation period divided by the convective turnover time, the time a parcel of gas takes to rise and sink once in the star’s outer layers; activity indicators across cool stars line up best against this ratio, the period divided by the convective turnover time. Replacing the period by the Rossby number makes the fit worse for each of five published turnover-time scales, in every one of 10,000 resamples. Past the fully convective boundary the smaller TESS sample also shows a flat hazard and lifetimes proportional to the period, though there the simulations can neither put a bound on aging nor tell a lifetime fixed in days from one fixed in rotations.

A scatter plot of median feature lifetime L in days, on a logarithmic vertical axis from 10 to about 350, against rotation period P in days, on a logarithmic horizontal axis from 5 to about 45, for 438 Kepler stars: black open circles for the G-K sample at periods of about 5 to 15 days and blue open triangles for the early-M sample extending to about 45 days, with symbol size growing with the number of feature deaths recorded on the star. Both kinds of symbol follow one rising band about an orange straight line labeled fit L = 10^0.868 P^0.828; a note at the top reads against rotation period: rms 0.1443 dex.

The rotation period sets how long a starspot feature lives. Each symbol is one Kepler star: its median feature lifetime in days against its rotation period in days, circles for Sun-like G and K dwarfs and triangles for the cooler early-M dwarfs, drawn larger for stars with more recorded feature deaths. Both classes fall along one band about the fitted power law $L = 10^{0.868}\,P^{0.828}$ days (orange line), with a scatter of 0.144 dex about it (a dex is a factor of ten in lifetime). Plotted against the Rossby number instead, the two classes separate and the scatter grows: to 0.198 dex with the turnover times of Wright et al. (2011), and to between 0.212 and 0.226 dex with the other four published turnover scales the paper tried. (Panel b of Figure 3 of the starspot paper.)

The Sun would not make it into the stellar sample, since its variability falls below the selection cut. Forward-modeled as a Kepler target it yields fewer than two trackable features per year of solar maximum and at most 13 in any four-year window, against the fifty a survival fit needs. The two results need not conflict if a light-curve feature is read as the stellar counterpart of a sunspot nest, a site where new spot groups emerge again and again. In a model of a site fed new groups at a steady rate, the site’s hazard settles to a constant once it is older than one or two member lifetimes, however the members age. On the Sun, where nests can be identified directly, the nests show no aging (in a test that would detect only strong aging), while the groups inside them do.

The nest picture does not fully reconcile the solar and stellar results, however. No feeding configuration tested reproduces the flat stellar hazard together with the observed lifetimes and depths: complexes assembled from groups that age by the solar law still show aging when put through the same analysis, and so does the one configuration tried with memoryless member groups. Either stellar features are fed faster, by shorter-lived groups, than scaled-up solar groups would supply, or the solar death law does not extrapolate to spots far larger than the Sun’s. Doppler imaging of one heavily spotted dwarf, rotation after rotation, would settle which.

The papers

References

B. Gompertz, On the nature of the function expressive of the law of human mortality, and on a new mode of determining the value of life contingencies, Phil. Trans. R. Soc. Lond. 115 (1825) 513the exponentially rising law of human mortality that the eroding-root hazard reproduces
M. N. Gnevyshev, On the nature of solar activity, Izv. Glav. Astron. Obs. Pulkove 16 (1938) 36decay at a rate set by present size, the origin of the lifetime–area law
H. W. Newton and M. L. Nunn, The Sun’s rotation derived from sunspots 1934–1944 and additional results, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 111 (1951) 413the rotation law used to match eastern reappearances to western exits
M. Waldmeier, Ergebnisse und Probleme der Sonnenforschung, 2nd ed., Geest & Portig, Leipzig (1955)with Gnevyshev, the constant-rate decay tradition and $\tau = \alpha A_{\max}$
B. L. Strehler and A. S. Mildvan, General theory of mortality and aging, Science 132 (1960) 14a declining reserve meeting random blows; the construction the eroding-root hazard borrows
G. W. Simon and R. B. Leighton, Velocity fields in the solar atmosphere. III. Large-scale motions, the chromospheric network, and magnetic fields, Astrophys. J. 140 (1964) 1120spot death by erosion from the surrounding convection
B. W. Turnbull, The empirical distribution function with arbitrarily grouped, censored and truncated data, J. R. Stat. Soc. B 38 (1976) 290the estimator that extracts a survival curve from interval-censored records
J. W. Vaupel, K. G. Manton and E. Stallard, The impact of heterogeneity in individual frailty on the dynamics of mortality, Demography 16 (1979) 439frailty: a fixed, unobserved multiplier on each individual’s hazard
K. Petrovay and F. Moreno-Insertis, Turbulent erosion of magnetic flux tubes, Astrophys. J. 485 (1997) 398the quantitative theory of turbulent erosion of a spot’s flux tube
N. J. Wright, J. J. Drake, E. E. Mamajek and G. W. Henry, The stellar-activity–rotation relationship and the evolution of stellar dynamos, Astrophys. J. 743 (2011) 48the rotation–activity relation; its turnover times give the Rossby number plotted above
H. A. C. Giles, A. Collier Cameron and R. D. Haywood, A Kepler study of starspot lifetimes with respect to light-curve amplitude and spectral type, Mon. Not. R. Astron. Soc. 472 (2017) 1618starspot decay timescales from Kepler light-curve autocorrelation, by spectral type
K. Namekata, H. Maehara, Y. Notsu, S. Toriumi, H. Hayakawa, K. Ikuta, S. Notsu, S. Honda, D. Nogami and K. Shibata, Lifetimes and emergence/decay rates of star spots on solar-type stars estimated by Kepler data in comparison with those of sunspots, Astrophys. J. 871 (2019) 187individually tracked spots on Sun-like Kepler stars, with lifetimes rising with rotation period
T. Baranyi, L. Győri and A. Ludmány, On-line tools for solar data compiled at the Debrecen observatory and their extensions with the Greenwich sunspot data, Sol. Phys. 291 (2016) 3081the Debrecen Photoheliographic Data, the independent spot-group catalog on which the age term is re-measured
D. H. Hathaway, Royal Greenwich Observatory and USAF/NOAA sunspot group records, 1874–present, solarcyclescience.com/activeregions.html (2024)the compiled daily group catalog from which the registry is threaded
SILSO World Data Center, The International Sunspot Number, 13-month smoothed monthly total, version 2, Royal Observatory of Belgium, Brussels (2026)the sunspot-number series that dates the cycle maxima and the decline after each

← back to the web summaries