The Great Oxidation (earth science)

How did Earth's air get its oxygen? A minimal model of the ocean and atmosphere, built from published chemistry and the rock record, suggests that the rise about 2.4 billion years ago arrived as a flicker paced by ice ages rather than as a single step. Includes a short film.

How Earth’s air got its oxygen (7½ minutes) — Matthew Schwartz · David Johnston · Claude: the history of Earth’s atmosphere from a young airless planet to today, and how a model built from published chemistry, climate and rock records finds the rise of oxygen 2.4 billion years ago arriving, on its assumptions, as a flicker paced by four ice ages rather than a single step. Images: NASA, USGS, NOAA and other public domain · CC BY 2.0: G. Churchard, J. St. John, NPS/M. Jenkins, owamux, P. Whitehouse · CC BY 3.0: CSIRO.

Air without oxygen

Oxygen is a fifth of the air today, yet for roughly the first half of the planet’s four-and-a-half-billion-year history it was almost absent. The change that began about 2.4 billion years ago is the Great Oxidation Event, which textbooks draw as the first permanent step of a staircase up to today’s air.

The clearest evidence for that early lack of oxygen is a signature in sulfur. Most chemistry sorts sulfur’s isotopes, atoms of slightly different weight, in proportion to their weight. Under an oxygen-free sky, ultraviolet sunlight acting on volcanic sulfur gases leaves a pattern that does not follow weight, and sediments lock it into rock. Farquhar, Bao and Thiemens reported this mass-independent fractionation, MIF-S for short, in 2000, in rocks older than the transition and not in younger ones. PhotochemicalPhotochemistry is chemistry driven by light: here, computer models of the reactions that ultraviolet sunlight sets off among the gases of the air. modeling by Pavlov and Kasting in 2002 showed that the signature survives only when oxygen is below about one hundred-thousandth ($10^{-5}$) of its present level.

Dated rocks on three old continental blocks, the Kola, Kaapvaal and Superior cratonsA craton is an old, stable block of continental crust. The Kaapvaal craton is in South Africa (its Transvaal rocks supply the sulfur record used here), the Superior craton in Canada (home of the Huronian rocks), and the Kola craton in the far north of Europe., now place the transition inside an interval of repeated glaciation. In South Africa the Makganyene glacial deposit, laid down at low latitude, interfingers with the Ongeluk lavas, which Gumsley and colleagues dated in 2017 to about 2,426 million years ago. Higher in the same succession, the Transvaal Supergroup, the sulfur anomaly is gone by 2.33 to 2.32 billion years ago. In more densely sampled drill coreA cylinder of rock a few centimeters across and up to kilometers long, cut by a hollow drill; depth down the core stands for time., though, it returns at least twice, and on that evidence Poulton and colleagues argued in 2021 that it was lost for good only near 2.22. Four glaciations fall in this interval under the current matching of the South African rocks with the Huronian rocks of Canada (three under an older matching). Geologists therefore increasingly read the Great Oxidation as a transition paced by climate.

Consider first what the 1,689 published sulfur measurements from South Africa can show by themselves. Because the measurements cluster at a few dated ages, there is no way to tell one oxic–anoxic cycle (air with oxygen, then without) from six by counting the flips between anomaly-bearing and anomaly-free rock. The case that the anomaly returned rests instead on the order of samples down individual drill cores, and the two readings of the record, a single loss of the anomaly and a loss followed by returns, both come from the same core, EBA-2.

Scatter plot of the sulfur-isotope anomaly, from 0 to about 9 parts per thousand, against age from 2.52 to 2.17 billion years ago, older ages on the left. Each of 1,689 small slate-gray dots is one measurement. The dots stand in a few narrow columns with almost nothing between them: near 2.49 billion years ago (values up to about 3.7), near 2.42 and 2.41 (up to about 3.5 apart from one point near 4.8, with a note that these two clusters have since been re-dated to about 2.45), a low scatter near 2.39, the tallest column near 2.37 (up to about 8.8), values near zero between 2.35 and 2.32, and short columns near 2.29 and 2.25 (up to about 2.9). A pale band from 2.50 to 2.43 is labeled: the rise of oxygen begins somewhere in this window. A hatched band from 2.33 to 2.22 is labeled: anomaly gone for good by 2.33 to 2.32 (one reading) or only by about 2.22 (another). Two notes read: large anomaly, oxygen-free sky; near zero, consistent with oxygen in the air.

The sulfur-isotope record of the Great Oxidation in South Africa. Each dot is one published measurement of the anomaly in rocks of the Transvaal basin, 1,689 in all, plotted at its reported age (the compilation of Uveges and colleagues, 2023; per mil means parts per thousand). A large anomaly means the sky above was essentially free of oxygen; values near zero are consistent with oxygenated air but do not prove it. The dots stand in a few columns because they come from a few dated rock units, so the record samples the state of the air at only a handful of moments. The pale band is the window in which the dated rocks place the onset of the transition; the two clusters just after it have since been re-dated into it (Senger and colleagues, 2023). The anomaly returns strongly near 2.37 billion years ago, and smaller anomalies recur in younger beds near 2.29 and 2.25. Whether it was gone for good by 2.33 or only by about 2.22 is the disagreement marked by the hatched span. (Data of Figure 4a of the paper in the layout of Figure S1 of its supplement, redrawn for the web.)

Why methane and ice belong in the story

Photochemical models had established that oxygen and methane destroy each other. Methane is also a greenhouse gas, and under a young Sun fainter than today’s it helped keep the early Earth warm, so losing it could freeze the planet. In a 2006 model by Claire, Catling and Zahnle, whose chemistry the model described below adopts, methane collapsed and recovered repeatedly and the planet froze three times.

In the present model, the methane comes from microbes that make it from hydrogen, and volcanoes supply the hydrogen; the same volcanic gases also consume oxygen directly. The decline of that hydrogen supply is dated with the nickel content of banded iron formationsFinely layered iron-rich rocks deposited from ancient seawater, mostly before the Great Oxidation; their chemistry records what the ocean held at the time, here the nickel that volcanic rock delivered., which falls from about 2.7 billion years ago, a decline attributed to the cooling of the planet’s interior. The compilers of that nickel record read the decline as a nickel famine for the methane-makers, which need the metal as a nutrient; the model reads it instead as a hydrogen famine. The model also takes as an input that the continents rose out of the sea between 2.55 and 2.45 billion years ago, and that rain on the newly exposed rock pulled more carbon dioxide from the air.

The ice ages come from the carbon cycle. When volcanic carbon dioxide can no longer keep the planet above its freezing threshold, ice spreads to the tropics in a snowball glaciation. Under global ice the weatheringThe chemical attack of rain and air on exposed rock. Dissolving silicate rock removes carbon dioxide from the air; oxidizing old organic carbon removes oxygen. that removes carbon dioxide stops while volcanoes keep supplying it, so the gas builds up until greenhouse warming is strong enough to melt the ice; weathering in the hothouse that follows then draws it back down, and the planet can freeze again. Climate models by Tajika in 2007 and others since showed such a planet cycling between frozen and ice-free states with a period set by the outgassingThe release of gases such as carbon dioxide and hydrogen from the planet’s interior through volcanoes and vents; stronger when the interior was hotter. rate. All the while the Sun brightens steadily, which makes freezing harder as time goes on.

The model

The model couples the oxygen–methane chemistry, the carbon cycle and the ice, and is deliberately minimal. It follows oxygen $O$, methane $N$ and carbon dioxide $C$ in the air, phosphate $P$ in the ocean, and an ice state, from three billion years ago to today. Every input is a published measurement or rate law, a quantity fixed by today’s steady state, a dated history, or a stated assumption varied later. Only one quantity, the outgassing exponent $\nu$ introduced below, is left free, and the glacial record fixes it. (The rule for the carbon outgassed under ice, described below, was chosen over an alternative partly because it gives four glaciations, so the glaciation count calibrates that rule as well.) With a dot for a rate of change, the oxygen and methane budgets are

$$ n_{\rm O_2}\,\dot O \;=\; B_{\rm mar} \;-\; 2\,\Omega \;-\; W_{\rm ox}\,O^{1/2} \;-\; R(t) \quad (O\gt 0), \qquad\quad \dot N \;=\; G(t) \;-\; \Omega \;-\; k_{\rm esc}\,N, \qquad\quad \Omega \;=\; k_{\rm eff}(p_{\rm O_2},p_{\rm CH_4})\; n_{\rm O_2}\,O\,N . $$

$O$ is oxygen in units of its present level (the first balance applies while $O$ is above zero), $n_{\rm O_2}$ converts it to moles, and $N$ is the methane inventory; every term is a flux in trillions of moles per year. $B_{\rm mar}$ is marine organic burial, the oxygen source; $\Omega$ the mutual destruction, two oxygen molecules per methane, with a rate coefficient $k_{\rm eff}$ that itself depends on the oxygen and methane partial pressures $p_{\rm O_2}$ and $p_{\rm CH_4}$, taken from the 2006 photochemical model. $W_{\rm ox}\,O^{1/2}$ is the weathering of old organic carbon; $R(t)$ the oxygen-consuming volcanic gas and $G(t)$ the methane made from volcanic hydrogen, both declining along the nickel record; and $k_{\rm esc}N$ the escape of methane’s hydrogen to space. Through the Archean, the eon that ended 2.5 billion years ago, the sinks exceed the source and $O$ stays at essentially zero. The model does not compute when the source first overtakes the sinks; that epoch is set as an input at 2.44 billion years ago, inside the window the dated rocks allow.

Carbon dioxide grows by volcanic outgassing and falls by burial and by rock weathering, which strengthens as the continents emerge and stops under ice. Outgassing follows a law published by Krissansen-Totton and colleagues in 2018,

$$ V_{\rm out}(t) \;=\; V_{\rm mod}\left(1-\frac{t}{4.5~{\rm Gyr}}\right)^{-\nu} , $$

with $t$ the age, $V_{\rm mod}$ today’s volcanic carbon flux and $\nu$ an exponent that sets how much harder the young, hotter Earth outgassed; a larger $\nu$ means more early carbon dioxide and, once it is large enough, fewer glaciations. Krissansen-Totton and colleagues allowed $\nu$ anywhere from 0 to 1.46 with no preferred value.

Climate enters through the forcing $F$, the net heating of the planet measured against the pre-industrial Earth, and ice advances when $F$ falls below a threshold:

$$ F(C,p_{\rm CH_4},t) \;=\; F_{\rm CO_2}(C) \;+\; F_{\rm CH_4}(p_{\rm CH_4}) \;-\; \bigl[\,1-s(t)\,\bigr]\,Q_\odot , \qquad\quad F + D^\ast \lt 0 \quad \mbox{(glaciation begins)} . $$

The first two terms are the warming from carbon dioxide and methane, from published radiation calculations; the last is the shortfall in sunlight, $Q_\odot$ being what the Earth absorbs today and $s(t)$ the Sun’s brightness relative to today. $D^\ast$, 10.1 watts per square meter, is the deficit at which a modern climate model runs away to global ice, the most glaciation-prone value published. While the planet is frozen, most of the carbon outgassed under the ice goes into a store that is released at the thaw; this store is among the model’s largest assumptions, and the authors have identified nothing that would physically hold that much carbon and return it. The model also assumes that oxygen and methane made beneath the ice are consumed there, so that its air stays oxygen-free throughout a glaciation.

The glacial record then fixes $\nu$. Requiring at least four glaciations and none after 2.22 billion years ago confines it to 0.7075–0.7225, one percent of the range from 0 to 1.46; throughout that narrow band the model has exactly four. With $\nu$ above about 0.8 there is no glaciation at all and oxygen rises once and smoothly, which is the textbook step. Since $\nu$ was chosen by counting glaciations, the count, the spacing and the date of the last thaw are part of the calibration and are not evidence for or against the model.

What comes out

When the model is run forward, its late-Archean air holds about 280 parts per million of methane (about twice that under an alternative treatment of hydrogen escape). The methane thins to a few parts per million as the hydrogen supply wanes and the continents emerge. At 2.45 billion years ago the planet freezes: weathering has already cooled the climate almost to the freezing threshold, and the loss of the last two parts per million or so of methane triggers the glaciation. Carbon dioxide builds under the ice for about 25 million years until the ice melts; weathering then draws the gas down, and about 45 million years later the planet refreezes. The model goes through this cycle four times between 2.45 and 2.22 billion years ago with no periodic push from outside. This is the same limit cycleA self-sustaining oscillation that a system settles into on its own, with no periodic push from outside: here, carbon dioxide building up under the ice until the ice melts, then being weathered away until the planet freezes again. that Tajika and later climate modelers found, here set off by the methane collapse, and it ends when the brightening Sun keeps the drawdown from reaching the freezing threshold again.

Line chart of carbon dioxide in the model’s air, in multiples of the pre-industrial level from 0 to 330, against age from 2.52 to 2.14 billion years ago, older ages on the left. Four pale vertical bands mark the model’s ice ages, labeled 1st ice age, 2nd, 3rd and 4th, each about 25 million years wide and 43 to 49 million years apart. A violet curve declines gently from about 90 to 67 before the first band, then traces four sawteeth: inside each band it climbs steeply to a peak of about 280, 265, 250 and 240 at the band’s right edge, then falls back along a concave curve to about 65, 59 and 53 at the start of the next band; after the fourth peak it falls to about 45 and levels off. A dotted line through the four peaks, labeled melting threshold, slopes gently down; a dashed line through the troughs, labeled freezing threshold (falls slowly as the Sun brightens), slopes down from about 72 to 50. A key reads: each cycle, 1, under the ice CO2 from volcanoes builds up; 2, at the melting line the ice goes; 3, weathering then draws CO2 down until the planet refreezes. A note at the right reads: after the fourth thaw the drawdown no longer reaches the freezing line.

Carbon dioxide in the model across the Great Oxidation: the climate oscillator behind the four ice ages (pale bands). Under global ice the weathering that removes carbon dioxide stops while volcanoes keep supplying it, so it climbs until the greenhouse is strong enough to melt the ice at the dotted line. Weathering of the bare continents in the hothouse that follows pulls it back down to the freezing threshold (dashed), which drifts lower as the Sun brightens, and the planet freezes again 43 to 49 million years after each thaw. Nothing pushes the cycle from outside. After the fourth thaw the drawdown levels off above the threshold and the glacial era is over. The peaks just after each thaw depend on the assumed melting level and the carbon stored under the ice; the troughs, from 65 down to 53 times the pre-industrial level, are the model’s own prediction. (Model output of Figure 5e of the paper, redrawn for the web.)

Oxygen follows the glacial cycle without driving it. The first ice-free interval is still oxygen-free; oxygen first clears the sulfur-isotope threshold at 2.35 billion years ago, early in the second interval. Each later interval is more oxygenated than the last, because burial holds steady while the oxygen sink from volcanic gases keeps declining; once the transition is under way, that sink is inferred from the carbon-isotope recordThe ratio of heavy to light carbon in carbonate rocks over time, which tracks organic-carbon burial and hence the oxygen left behind.. The returns to anoxia during the glaciations come entirely from the assumption that oxygen and methane made beneath the ice are consumed there; without it the ice would not interrupt the rise at all. From the fourth thaw, 2.22 billion years ago, oxygen stays for good, though that date is set by the glaciation count and the same assumption, so it is not a prediction.

Line chart of oxygen in the model’s air as a fraction of today’s level, on a logarithmic axis from a billionth to a little under a thousandth, against age from 2.52 to 2.14 billion years ago, older ages on the left. Four pale vertical bands mark the model’s ice ages, labeled 1st ice age, 2nd, 3rd and 4th along the bottom. A dotted violet line runs along the floor of the plot, at a billionth, before the first band and inside each band, with the note: essentially no oxygen before the first ice age; none under the ice, by assumption (dotted). Between the bands a solid violet curve appears. After the first ice age it rises from about four ten-millionths to five millionths, staying below a dashed orange horizontal line at one hundred-thousandth labeled sulfur-isotope threshold, 1/100,000 of today’s oxygen, then drops back to the floor at the second ice age; a note reads first ice-free interval: still below threshold. After the second thaw the curve starts just below the threshold and crosses it almost at once, at an open circle labeled model: first oxic air at 2.353, 15 million years late; an orange bracket above, from 2.424 to 2.368, is labeled rocks: first oxic air between 2.424 and 2.368. After the third and fourth thaws the curve comes back higher each time, a few hundred-thousandths, and after the fourth it keeps rising smoothly toward a ten-thousandth with no further drop. A filled square on the threshold line at the fourth thaw is labeled oxygen stays from the last thaw, 2.217.

Oxygen in the model’s air across the Great Oxidation. The pale bands are the four glaciations of the previous figure. The dashed line is the sulfur-isotope threshold, one hundred-thousandth of today’s oxygen, below which the anomaly of the first figure can form. Before the first ice age the sinks outweigh the source and the air holds essentially no free oxygen; under each ice cover it holds none by assumption (dotted). The first ice-free interval stays below the threshold. Oxygen first clears it just after the second thaw, 2.353 billion years ago (open circle), 15 million years later than the youngest date the South African rocks allow for the first oxic air (orange bracket). Each later interval comes back more oxygenated, and from the fourth thaw, 2.217 billion years ago, oxygen stays (filled square). That last date follows from the glaciation count and the under-ice assumption and is not a test of the model. (Model output of Figure 5d of the paper at $\nu=0.715$, redrawn for the web.)

Two of the model’s glaciations agree with the dated rocks, and neither agreement follows from the glaciation count. The first, whose start is set by an input, spans the age of the Ongeluk lavas, and the fourth begins after the youngest ash beds beneath the last South African glacial deposit. The third, however, ends about 20 million years too late: the Gordon Lake tuffsA tuff is a bed of volcanic ash hardened into rock; zircon crystals in it can be dated precisely by the decay of uranium to lead, which makes tuffs the clocks of a sedimentary succession. in Canada, ash beds on top of the last Huronian glacial deposit, show that the ice was gone by 2.31 billion years ago, and the model keeps it until 2.29. That miss depends on the assumed under-ice carbon store: with the carbon locked in ocean crust instead, the model can meet the Gordon Lake date but then misses other dated beds.

The sulfur record is harder to match, and the outcome depends on what the anomaly needs in order to be preserved. If it needs only low oxygen, the model’s first oxic air comes 15 million years later than the South African rocks allow. If it also needs methane above about eight parts per million, as Zahnle and colleagues proposed in 2006, the model loses the anomaly before the first glaciation, which is too early for the anomaly-bearing beds in South Africa, and the later returns to anoxia then leave no sulfur trace. The model also fails to reproduce the Lomagundi–Jatuli excursion near 2.2 billion years ago, a large swing in the carbon-isotope makeup of carbonate rocks, and it falls short, by a factor of 800 or more, of the oxygen that later iron-retaining paleosolsA paleosol is an ancient soil preserved in the rock record; how much iron it kept or lost while it weathered records the oxygen of the air it formed under, and its other chemistry the carbon dioxide. require. The last two failures trace to the lack of any mechanism in the model for an oxygen overshoot.

Between glaciations the model’s carbon dioxide falls from as much as 253 times the pre-industrial level just after a thaw to as little as 53 times before the next freeze. The high values follow from the assumed melting level and the under-ice carbon store, but the minimum is the model’s own prediction and could be tested against a dated soil. Only two soils from the glacial era have been analyzed in enough detail to estimate the carbon dioxide they formed under, one near Ville Marie in Quebec and one at Hokkalampi in Finland. Worked out for both, the estimates overlap the model’s range, though most central values lie below half its minimum; because neither soil has been dated to a particular interval, the comparison does not yet count as a test.

Solving the stepwise model exactly

A prominent modern statement of the staircase picture is the 2019 ocean–atmosphere model of Alcott, Mills and Poulton, in which the planet’s own feedbacks turn a smooth decline in volcanic gases into oxygenation steps. That model can be solved exactly for all its steady states (balances in which nothing changes) at the settings Alcott, Mills and Poulton published; the calculation is in the supplement. At the settings of that model’s Great Oxidation, with the weakest feedbacks its authors consider, there is exactly one stable state, low in oxygen, and provably no oxygenated state coexists with it. Driven by its authors’ own declining input, the model oxygenates once and never returns to anoxia. The same method recovers both states of the two-state 2006 model of Goldblatt, Lenton and Watson.

What is settled and what is open

The main result carries two conditions: volcanic outgassing must have declined as steeply as the glaciations require, and oxygen and methane made beneath the ice must have been consumed there. If both hold, the model suggests, an episodic first rise of oxygen of the kind Poulton and colleagues inferred follows from published photochemistry and carbon-cycle laws driven by dated inputs. Even then, the glaciations depend on further choices: a freezing threshold close to the lowest anyone has published, an atmosphere holding about one bar of nitrogen, and continents emerged by 2.38 billion years ago. The model also leaves out the sulfur and iron cycles, carbonate chemistry and ocean geography, and covers only the transition itself. And since the epoch at which burial overtakes the sinks is an input read from the rocks, it cannot say whether a rising source or a falling sink caused the Great Oxidation.

The most decisive test would be an age good to a few million years for the end of the third glaciation, when the model’s planet is still frozen. The place to look is the top of the Gowganda glacial deposit in Canada or of the Rooihoogte in South Africa. A soil dated to an ice-free interval between 2.43 and 2.24 billion years ago would test the carbon cycle; a dated length or spacing of one glaciation would test the under-ice carbon store. Any glacial deposit or renewed sulfur anomaly above the Hekpoort lava, which caps the last South African glacial deposit, would contradict the model outright.

The paper

Supplementary material

References

J. Farquhar, H. Bao and M. Thiemens, Atmospheric influence of Earth’s earliest sulfur cycle, Science 289 (2000) 756the mass-independent sulfur-isotope anomaly in rocks older than the transition
A. A. Pavlov and J. F. Kasting, Mass-independent fractionation of sulfur isotopes in Archean sediments: strong evidence for an anoxic Archean atmosphere, Astrobiology 2 (2002) 27the anomaly survives only with oxygen below a hundred-thousandth of its present level
A. P. Gumsley, K. R. Chamberlain, W. Bleeker, U. Söderlund, M. O. de Kock, E. R. Larsson and A. Bekker, Timing and tempo of the Great Oxidation Event, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 114 (2017) 1811the Ongeluk lava age, about 2,426 million years, that dates the first glaciation
A. Bekker, H. D. Holland, P.-L. Wang, D. Rumble III, H. J. Stein, J. L. Hannah, L. L. Coetzee and N. J. Beukes, Dating the rise of atmospheric oxygen, Nature 427 (2004) 117the one-step loss of the anomaly by 2.32 billion years ago, read on drill core EBA-2
G. Luo, S. Ono, N. J. Beukes, D. T. Wang, S. Xie and R. E. Summons, Rapid oxygenation of Earth’s atmosphere 2.33 billion years ago, Sci. Adv. 2 (2016) e1600134the anomaly gone by 2.33 billion years ago, the earlier of the two loss dates marked in the first figure
S. W. Poulton, A. Bekker, V. M. Cumming, A. L. Zerkle, D. E. Canfield and D. T. Johnston, A 200-million-year delay in permanent atmospheric oxygenation, Nature 592 (2021) 232the anomaly returns in drill core; oxygen permanent only near 2.22 billion years ago
B. T. Uveges, G. Izon, S. Ono, N. J. Beukes and R. E. Summons, Reconciling discrepant minor sulfur isotope records of the Great Oxidation Event, Nat. Commun. 14 (2023) 279compiled the 1,689 South African sulfur-isotope analyses plotted in the first figure
M. H. Senger, J. H. F. L. Davies, M. Ovtcharova, N. Beukes, A. Gumsley, S. P. Gaynor, A. Ulianov, R. Ngobeli and U. Schaltegger, Improving the chronostratigraphic framework of the Transvaal Supergroup (South Africa) through in-situ and high-precision U-Pb geochronology, Precambrian Res. 392 (2023) 107070the re-dating of the Koegas Subgroup samples to about 2.45 billion years ago noted in the first figure
M. W. Claire, D. C. Catling and K. J. Zahnle, Biogeochemical modelling of the rise in atmospheric oxygen, Geobiology 4 (2006) 239the oxygen–methane photochemistry the model adopts; its planet froze three times
K. Zahnle, M. Claire and D. Catling, The loss of mass-independent fractionation in sulfur due to a Palaeoproterozoic collapse of atmospheric methane, Geobiology 4 (2006) 271the proposal that keeping the anomaly also needs methane above about 8 parts per million
E. Tajika, Long-term stability of climate and global glaciations throughout the evolution of the Earth, Earth Planets Space 59 (2007) 293a planet short of volcanic carbon dioxide cycles between frozen and ice-free states
J. Krissansen-Totton, G. N. Arney and D. C. Catling, Constraining the climate and ocean pH of the early Earth with a geological carbon cycle model, Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 115 (2018) 4105the carbon-cycle and outgassing laws, with the exponent $\nu$ left anywhere from 0 to 1.46
B. Rasmussen, J.-W. Zi and A. Bekker, New U-Pb zircon tuff ages and revised stratigraphic correlations in the Superior craton during the Great Oxidation Episode, Earth Planet. Sci. Lett. 640 (2024) 118779the Gordon Lake tuff ages that the model’s third glaciation overruns by about 20 million years
L. J. Alcott, B. J. W. Mills and S. W. Poulton, Stepwise Earth oxygenation is an inherent property of global biogeochemical cycling, Science 366 (2019) 1333the stepwise model whose steady states are solved exactly in the supplement
C. Goldblatt, T. M. Lenton and A. J. Watson, Bistability of atmospheric oxygen and the Great Oxidation, Nature 443 (2006) 683the two-state model; the same exact method recovers both of its states

← back to the web summaries