Feynman diagrams (quantum field theory)

Thirty frontier Feynman integrals computed in closed form. Fifteen of these were already known, at least at the level of the $\varepsilon$ form, and are independently reproduced end-to-end with the BootLoops toolkit. Fifteen are new. Each integral has its own page and code to evaluate the integral to the BootLoops standard.

The 30 diagrams. Click each for details.

Non-planar two-loop diagram for quark–antiquark annihilation into two W bosons: gluon exchanges on the left, two doubled lines carrying the top-quark mass on the right, and two internal lines that cross Two-loop diagram for two gluons producing a Z boson and a photon: a massless loop attached to a box of doubled top-quark lines from which the Z and the photon are emitted Two-loop triangle of doubled top-quark lines with an internal wavy line of mass M across it, two gluons entering and a dashed Higgs line leaving Non-planar two-loop five-point diagram, a pentagon loop joined to a crossed box, with two massive W legs and three massless legs Planar two-loop double box whose six outer lines are doubled and massive, with a thin massless middle line and four massless external legs Planar two-loop double box with all seven internal lines and all four external legs massless Planar two-loop double box with massless outer lines and legs and a single doubled massive line in the middle One-loop pentagon with five thin massless internal lines and five massless external legs Two-loop vertex diagram with six massless internal lines, one off-shell leg entering at the top and two massless legs leaving at the bottom Three-loop ladder diagram, a double box attached to a triangle, with nine massless internal lines, two off-shell legs and one massless leg Box of doubled massive electron lines with a wavy photon at each corner; the top side of the box is replaced by a sunrise of three massive lines Box of doubled massive electron lines with four external photons; the bottom side of the box is replaced by a kite self-energy of massive and massless lines Box of doubled massive electron lines with four external photons and an internal wavy photon exchanged along the bottom side of the box, ten lines in all Box of doubled massive electron lines with four external photons; a photon radiated from the bottom line of the box carries a massive fermion loop Box of doubled massive fermion lines with four external photons and two wavy photon diagonals that cross inside the box Two-point sunrise diagram: three doubled lines of the same mass joining two vertices between thin external legs Sunrise diagram with three massive lines in two colors, two of one mass and one heavier, squared masses 1, 1 and 2 Sunrise diagram with three massive lines in three colors for three different masses, squared masses 1, 2 and 3 Sunrise diagram with three massive lines in two colors, two of one mass and one heavier, squared masses 1, 1 and 4 Sunrise diagram with three massive lines of different colors, marked epsilon to the one for the next order in the dimensional regulator Kite diagram, a rhombus with one diagonal: three doubled lines of mass m form the sunrise sub-diagram and two thin massless lines sit on opposite sides Kite diagram with doubled massive lines of masses 1, 1 and root 2 in two colors and two thin massless lines on opposite sides of the rhombus Kite diagram whose four rim lines carry four different masses in four colors, joined by a thin massless vertical rung Ice-cream-cone diagram: a triangle of doubled lines of one mass with a two-line bubble on its top edge and three external legs Ice-cream-cone diagram with four internal lines in four colors for four different masses, a two-line scoop on top of a triangle Ice-cream-cone diagram with internal lines in four colors, marked epsilon to the one for the next order in the dimensional regulator Three-loop banana diagram: four doubled lines of the same mass joining two vertices between thin external legs Four-loop banana diagram: five doubled lines of the same mass joining two vertices between thin external legs Three-loop banana with three lines of one mass and one heavier line in a second color whose mass equals the sum of the other three Four-loop banana with four lines of one mass and one thick heavier line whose mass equals the sum of the other four
The BootLoops standard

An integral counts as computed here only when it meets three requirements, together called the BootLoops standard. First, an explicit closed form in a declared function class, in which every constant is a classical one or is defined by a convergent integral or series written out with the result. Second, agreement to thirty digits or more with independent numerical values at stated kinematic points that were withheld from the derivation, entering no fit and no boundary determination, with the comparison repeated at two working precisions. Third, a stand-alone evaluator, containing no reduction or auxiliary-mass-flow code, that anyone can run at any point and precision and that reproduces those checks. What counts as a closed form depends on the function class:

The problem

Feynman diagrams are the line drawings physicists use to compute what happens when particles collide. Each diagram stands for a definite integral over the momenta of the particles circulating inside it, whose value is the diagram’s contribution to the prediction. Diagrams with loops carry the quantum corrections: each added loop makes the prediction more precise and the integral much harder, and at the Large Hadron Collider, where new physics is sought as a discrepancy between a precise measurement and an equally precise prediction, loop integrals are the limiting step on the theory side.

In the conventions used here, a family of integrals with $L$ loops and $n$ internal lines is

$$ I_{\nu_1\cdots\nu_n}\big(d;\{s_{ij}\},\{m_i^2\}\big) \;=\; \int\prod_{l=1}^{L}\frac{d^dk_l}{i\pi^{d/2}}\;\prod_{j=1}^{n}\frac{1}{D_j^{\,\nu_j}}\,, \qquad D_j=q_j^2-m_j^2+i0\,. $$

Here the $k_l$ are the loop momenta in $d$ dimensions, $D_j$ is the propagator of the $j$-th internal line with momentum $q_j$ and mass $m_j$ (the $+i0$ fixes on which side of its pole each propagator is evaluated), the invariants $s_{ij}=(p_i+p_j)^2$ of the external momenta are the kinematic variables, and the integer powers $\nu_j$ select one member of the family. The integrals diverge in four dimensions, so they are computed in $d=4-2\varepsilon$ and expanded in $\varepsilon$; each result below is one coefficient of that expansion, usually the finite $\varepsilon^0$ term, as an explicit function of the masses and invariants.

How hard such an integral is depends on the class of functions its answer needs, and that class can be read off the diagram before anything is computed. Putting every internal line on its mass shellA particle is on its mass shell when its energy and momentum obey the relation $E^2=p^2+m^2$ of a real, observable particle; particles inside a loop need not. gives the maximal cut of the integral; the components of the loop momenta that those conditions do not fix sweep out a geometric object, and its shape determines the function class. When it is a sphere, the answer is built from polylogarithms, the functions obtained from the logarithm by repeated integration. Make enough of the internal lines massive and the sphere becomes a torus, that is, an elliptic curve, whose own functions the answer then needs: its periodsThe two numbers obtained by integrating the curve’s natural differential once around each of the two independent cycles of the torus; every function attached to the curve is built from them., elliptic generalizations of the polylogarithm, and iterated integrals of modular formsFunctions of the shape of the torus that transform in a prescribed way when the same torus is described by a different pair of cycles; their integrals supply the constants that elliptic Feynman integrals contain.. The standard example is the two-loop sunrise, one particle splitting into three massive particles that recombine, solved several times in different function languages. Adding loops to the sunrise gives the banana graphs: the torus gives way to a K3 surface at three loops and a Calabi–Yau threefold at four, for which still less of the calculus exists.

The one-loop problem was solved as a class: in 1979 Passarino and Veltman reduced every one-loop amplitude to a few standard integrals, all logarithms and dilogarithms. Beyond one loop, the integration-by-parts identities of Chetyrkin and Tkachov (1981) relate the integrals of a family, and Laporta’s algorithm (2000) solves them for a short list of master integralsA finite set of integrals of the family in terms of which every other member can be written with rational coefficients; computing the family means computing these.. These satisfy differential equations in the kinematic variables, so computing a family becomes solving that system from a point where the integrals are known (Gehrmann and Remiddi, 2000). The symbol of Goncharov, Spradlin, Vergu and Volovich (2010) encodes a polylogarithmic function as the sequence of logarithmic arguments it is built from, and Henn (2013) observed that a good choice of master integrals factors $\varepsilon$ out of the differential equations (the canonical form), which are then solved order by order by linear algebra plus a boundary value. Numerically, the auxiliary-mass-flow method of Liu and Ma (2022) gives any master integral to hundreds of digits at a chosen point, though not its analytic form.

Beyond the polylogarithms there is no general algorithm that brings the differential equations to canonical form, only constructions found family by family, and no finite set of logarithmic arguments from which to build a symbol. The reduction and numerical programs run the same way whatever the function class, and give no hint of which class it is. Sabry wrote down the two-loop sunrise in 1962; Laporta and Remiddi evaluated it analytically on its elliptic curve only in 2005. In 2023 Pögel, Wang and Weinzierl brought the differential equation of the four-loop banana, a Calabi–Yau integral, to $\varepsilon$-factorized form. Even the location of an integral’s singularities, governed by the Landau equations of 1959, became computable from the graph alone only with the Landau discriminants of Mizera and Telen (2021) and the programs PLD.jl (2023) and SOFIA (2025).

A horizontal time axis from 1947 to 2026 with ticks every decade and a small Feynman diagram at each landmark. Above the axis, in black: 1947, one-loop vertex (g minus 2), drawn as a fermion line with a wavy photon loop; 1999, massless double box, two squares side by side with four external legs; 2010, the symbol, drawn as a hexagon with six legs; 2018, two-loop five-point, a pentagon joined to a box; 2026, thirty integrals, drawn as the ice-cream cone, a triangle carrying a red doubled bubble. Below the axis: 1957, two-loop vertex, a fermion line with two photon loops; then in red doubled lines the sunrise family, 2005 elliptic sunrise with three lines between two points, 2015 K3 banana with four lines, 2023 Calabi–Yau banana with five lines. A gray double arrow spanning roughly 1960 to 1998 is labeled four decades of slow, hard-won progress.

Figure 1. Landmarks in the computation of multi-loop Feynman integrals, 1947–2026, each drawn as a small diagram at its year. Black diagrams are polylogarithmic: the one-loop vertex behind the electron’s anomalous magnetic moment (1947) and its two-loop successor (1957, below the axis), the massless double box (1999), the hexagon that stands for the symbol (2010) and the two-loop five-point integrals (2018). Red doubled lines are massive: the sunrise and banana graphs, the same two-point diagram with one more massive line per loop, evaluated on an elliptic curve in 2005, a K3 surface in 2015 and a Calabi–Yau threefold in 2023. The gray arrow marks the four decades between the two-loop vertex and the massless double box. The 2026 mark stands for the thirty integrals summarized here, with the ice-cream cone drawn for them. (Drawn for this page.)

The word bootstrap here names a strategy: instead of integrating, write down every function the answer could be built from, then cut that set down with everything known about the answer’s analytic structure until one candidate is left. The strategy is mature for polylogarithmic amplitudes, and Morales, Spiering, Wilhelm, Yang and Zhang carried it to elliptic integrals at the level of the symbol in 2022. The two methods extended here both stopped at the elliptic curve, where there was no enumerable function space to fit: a Landau bootstrap, which constrains an integral from its behavior near its singularities, and analytic regression, which recognizes an integral’s exact coefficients from samples accurate to hundreds of digits. Meanwhile several integrals that collider predictions depend on had no closed form: the non-planar two-loop integrals for W-pair production ($q\bar q \to W^+W^-$) with the top-quark mass kept exact, the elliptic master integrals for $gg \to Z\gamma$, and the two-loop five-point integrals for a pair of vector bosons produced with a jet.

The approach

BootLoops computes each integral by one of two routes. The first, constrain-and-fit, starts from the function space that the geometry of the maximal cut allows. Exact constraints, namely where the answer may be singular, how it behaves there and which symmetries it has, remove almost every candidate, and the few remaining constants are fitted to high-precision numerical values of the integral and recognized as exact numbers by integer-relation (PSLQ) searches. The second, reduce-and-transport, reduces the family to master integrals, constructs their differential equation and solves it along a path from a point where the integrals are known exactly. Both routes rest on the differential equation in Henn’s canonical form,

$$ d\,\vec g \;=\; \varepsilon\, A\,\vec g \,, \qquad\qquad dA \;=\; A \wedge A \,.$$

Here $\vec g$ is the vector of master integrals, each normalized to uniform weight (the number of nested integrations), and $A$ is a matrix of one-forms in the kinematic variables. For polylogarithmic integrals $A=\sum_k A_k\, d\log \alpha_k$ with constant rational matrices $A_k$ and letters $\alpha_k$, algebraic functions of the kinematics that mark every possible branch point; on an elliptic curve or a Calabi–Yau manifold forms built from the periods replace the $d\log$ forms. Because $\varepsilon$ multiplies the whole right-hand side, the solution at each order in $\varepsilon$ is an iterated integral of these forms, so the function space can be enumerated. The second equation says that $A$ is a flat connection, so the result cannot depend on the path of integration; when there are several kinematic variables this is the strongest single constraint. The answer is then written as

$$ I \;=\; \mathrm{LS}(x) \sum_{w} c_w\, f_w(x)\,,$$

with $x$ the kinematic variables, $\mathrm{LS}(x)$ the leading singularity (the prefactor read off the maximal cut), $f_w$ the iterated integrals labeled by words $w$ in the letters, and $c_w$ the rational coefficients and boundary constants that the constraints and the fit determine.

The geometry of the maximal cut also determines which of the two routes applies. An elliptic curve has two independent periods, and the maximal cut supplies only the first. When a master integral’s normalization involves only that period, a fit of values can succeed. When the normalization also involves an integral of a modular form over the kinematic variable (an Eichler integralAn integral of a modular form, taken from the point where the torus degenerates; it plays the role for elliptic Feynman integrals that the dilogarithm plays at one loop., which no cut supplies), no fit of numerical values alone can succeed, and the integral is computed by the second route from a boundary value derived in closed form. The class of integrals these methods reach is described on a page of its own.

Every result below is held to the BootLoops standard, and each integral page carries its three items: the closed form, the checks and the evaluator. Fifteen of the thirty integrals are known results rederived by these routes with the published answer withheld until the final comparison; the method was first tested that way on the outer-mass double box of Caron-Huot and Henn (2014). Computer-algebra and numerical programs compute every number and every symbol. The language model (Claude) sets up each problem, chooses the route, runs those programs and assembles the result, and whether a result meets that standard never depends on the model’s judgment.

The results

In the table each name links to the integral’s own page and each function class to a short primer.

integralloops; legs; massesfunction classstatus
Collider amplitudes with exact masses
Non-planar two-loop W-pair production2; 4; two of mass $m_t$ellipticnew
$gg\to Z\gamma$ with exact top-quark mass2; 4; top-quark loop of mass $m_t$ellipticnew
Elliptic master integrals for $gg\to H$2; 3; five of $m_t$, one of $M$ellipticknown result, rederived
Non-planar hexa-box with two massive legs2; 5; none (legs $p_1^2=p_3^2=m^2$)polylognew
Outer-mass double box2; 4; six of mass $m$polylogknown result, rederived
Massless planar double box2; 4; nonepolylogknown result, rederived
Central-mass double box2; 4; one of mass $m$polylogknown result, rederived
One-loop massless pentagon1; 5; nonepolylogknown result, rederived
Two-loop Sudakov form factor2; 3; nonepolylogknown result, rederived
Three-loop ladder3; 3; nonepolylogknown result, rederived
Three-loop QED light-by-light
Light-by-light box with a sunrise insertion3; 4; six of mass $m$ellipticnew
Light-by-light box with a kite insertion3; 4; one mass $m$ellipticnew
Ten-line QED light-by-light graphs, photon exchanged along one side3; 4; one mass $m$ellipticnew
Light-by-light box with a vacuum-polarization insertion3; 4; one mass $m$ellipticnew
Crossed light-by-light box3; 4; four of mass $m$polylog + K3new
Two-point families and their geometries
Equal-mass sunrise2; 2; three of mass $m$ellipticknown result, rederived
Sunrise, squared masses $(1,1,2)$2; 2; squared masses $(1,1,2)$ellipticknown result, rederived
Sunrise, squared masses $(1,2,3)$2; 2; squared masses $(1,2,3)$ellipticknown result, rederived
Sunrise, squared masses $(1,1,4)$2; 2; squared masses $(1,1,4)$ellipticknown result, rederived
Sunrise, order $\varepsilon^1$2; 2; the three mass sets aboveellipticknown result, rederived
Equal-mass kite2; 2; three of mass $m$ellipticknown result, rederived
Unequal-mass kite2; 2; squared masses $(1,1,2)$ellipticnew
Four-mass kite with a massless rung2; 2; squared masses $(1,4,9,2)$, rung $0$polylognew
Equal-mass ice-cream cone2; 3; four of mass $m$ellipticnew
Ice-cream cone with generic masses2; 3; squared masses $(1,2,3,5)$ellipticnew
Ice-cream cone, order $\varepsilon^1$2; 3; as the two cones aboveellipticnew
Three-loop equal-mass banana3; 2; four of mass $m$K3known result, rederived
Four-loop equal-mass banana4; 2; five of mass $m$Calabi–Yauknown result, rederived
Three-loop banana at the mass threshold3; 2; squared masses $(1,1,1,9)$K3new
Four-loop banana at the mass threshold4; 2; squared masses $(1,1,1,1,16)$Calabi–Yaunew

The largest new result is the non-planar family of two-loop W-pair production, $q\bar q\to W^+W^-$ with the top-quark mass kept exact. In 2024 He and collaborators computed the master integrals of the three planar topologies, which they call branches, and left the non-planar one to future work. That branch has 76 master integrals, 23 of them not computed before, among them a group sharing a sub-diagram whose maximal cut is an elliptic curve absent from the planar branches. The non-planar branch is solved here in explicit form along a one-parameter slice of the kinematics (two of the three kinematic variables held fixed), with every boundary constant derived, and the closed form agrees with independent numerical evaluations to 37 digits at two points.

The two elliptic master integrals of gluon fusion into a Z boson and a photon with the full top-quark mass dependence are given in closed form, with every boundary constant derived analytically: the elliptic boundary value is an Eichler integral of a modular form for the group $\Gamma_0(4)$, and Catalan’s constant is the other transcendental that enters. The closed form agrees with independent numerical evaluations to 126 digits. For two vector bosons produced with a jet the integrals are non-planar two-loop five-point hexa-boxes (a pentagon loop joined to a crossed box). The simplest family, with the two massive legs at non-adjacent corners, is given in closed form, and 13 of its master integrals had not been computed before. Its three top-sector integrals, those with every line of the diagram present, are given as explicit layered iterated integrals along a path through the kinematic space rather than as polylogarithms.

Light-by-light scattering, photons scattering off photons through a loop of massive charged particles, requires at three loops a family of QED integrals for which no closed form has been published. Five members are computed here. Four involve a self-energy on one side of the one-loop massive box: the box with a sunrise inserted on one line, whose boundary constant is $2\,\mathrm{Cl}_2(\pi/3)$ with $\mathrm{Cl}_2$ the Clausen function; the box with a kite inserted, the kite being the two-loop self-energy drawn as a rhombus with one diagonal; the ten-line QED graphs with a photon exchanged along one side of the box, of which the kite insertion is a limiting case; and the box with a vacuum-polarization insertion. The last three follow from a dispersion relation: the inserted self-energy is written as an integral over single lines of squared mass $w$, weighted by a spectral density $\rho(w)$. In units where the electron mass is $m=1$, the kite’s spectral density below the three-particle threshold $w=9m^2$ is

$$\rho(w)=-\frac{\pi}{w}\Big[2\ln(w-1)\ln w+3\,\mathrm{Li}_2(1-w)\Big],\qquad m^2\le w\le 9m^2,$$

and the three-loop integral is $\frac1\pi\int_{m^2}^\infty\!\rho(w)\,\mathrm{Box}_1(s,t;w)\,\mathrm{d}w$, where $\mathrm{Box}_1(s,t;w)$ is the one-loop box whose inserted line carries squared mass $w$, a combination of dilogarithms of the two photon invariants $s$ and $t$. Above $w=9m^2$ the density is a one-fold integral over the period of the sunrise’s elliptic curve, and the elliptic functions of the result come only from that region. The fifth member is the crossed light-by-light box, in which the two photon lines cross inside the massive fermion loop. Its top-sector integral is an iterated integral over the period of a K3 surface, given here as an explicit list of words, iterated integrals over thirteen kernels built from that period.

Several of the new results are single numbers. A banana graph is at threshold, in the sense used here, when the mass of its heaviest line equals the sum of the other masses. With the masses fixed that way, the three-loop banana’s period, expanded in the external momentum squared $p^2$ about $p^2=0$, contains a term $c_{3/2}\,(p^2)^{3/2}$ with $c_{3/2}=-\sqrt{3}/(36\pi)$, which follows in closed form from the monodromyHow the solutions of the differential equation transform into one another when carried once around a singular point. there; in the four-loop banana the coefficients $c_{5/4}$ and $c_{7/4}$ of $(p^2)^{5/4}$ and $(p^2)^{7/4}$ lie in the ring of constants generated by $\Gamma(\tfrac14)$. The two-loop ice-cream cone, a massive triangle with a bubble on one edge, reduces to a single boundary constant that is a new period, written as an explicit convergent integral. For equal masses it lives on the sunrise’s own elliptic curve, yet integer-relation searches find no expression for it in the sunrise’s periods and classical constants. For generic masses the curve is not described by modular forms, and the searches again find nothing classical. The same closed form exhibits, as an explicit nonzero number, the cone’s violation of the hierarchical principle of Landshoff, Olive and Polkinghorne from the S-matrix program of the 1960s, the rule that a diagram should have no singularity that none of its sub-diagrams has, to which the ice-cream cone is the known counterexample.

Feynman geometry

In the threshold configuration of the sunrise and banana graphs the heaviest line’s mass equals the sum of the others (squared masses $(1,1,4)$ for the sunrise, $(1,1,1,9)$ and $(1,1,1,1,16)$ for the bananas), and at the point $p^2=0$ two of the graph’s singular points merge, so the modular-form expansions used at other special points do not exist. There the sunrise’s elliptic curve degenerates through a fiber of Type III in Kodaira’s classification of degenerating elliptic curves, with local monodromy of order four. In the ordinary (semistable) degeneration one cycle of the torus pinches to a point, and every degeneration of the equal-mass sunrise’s curve is of that kind; this one is not, and it is the first non-semistable degeneration identified so far for the elliptic curve of a Feynman integral. The order of the threshold monodromy alternates with the loop number: 4, 2, 4 at two, three and four loops, read from the exact Picard–Fuchs operators (the differential operators the periods satisfy), and 2 at five loops on a two-mass slice, whose reading as a threshold is conjectural. The threshold constants quoted above follow the same alternation: the $\Gamma(\tfrac14)$ ring of the four-loop coefficients already appears in the $(1,1,4)$ sunrise at that point, the other order-four case, while the three-loop constant $c_{3/2}$ contains no $\Gamma(\tfrac14)$.

The banana ladder: four two-point graphs in a row joined by arrows, each with one more doubled red massive line between the same two vertices and thin external legs. First, the one-loop bubble with two lines, labeled sphere, logarithms. Second, the two-loop sunrise with three lines, labeled elliptic curve, modular forms. Third, the three-loop banana with four lines, labeled K3 surface. Fourth, the four-loop banana with five lines, labeled Calabi–Yau threefold.

Figure 2. The banana ladder. The same two-point graph gains one massive line per loop: the one-loop bubble, the two-loop sunrise, and the three- and four-loop bananas. The geometry of the maximal cut climbs with it, from a sphere (logarithms) to an elliptic curve (modular forms) to a K3 surface to a Calabi–Yau threefold.

Three of the results are proofs that an answer of a given kind does not exist. The first, used above to choose between the two routes, is that the $gg\to Z\gamma$ boundary value cannot be fitted from numerical values alone. The second is that the crossed light-by-light box’s top-sector integral has no polylogarithmic form in any basis, with the proof on its page. The third concerns periods of weight three, the kind a K3 surface carries. The K3 surface of the three-loop banana has periods built from two copies of the equal-mass sunrise’s elliptic curve, which has complex multiplication by $\mathbb{Q}(\sqrt{-15})$ (an extra arithmetic symmetry of special elliptic curves). A weight-three period without complex multiplication would be a new kind of number for Feynman integrals. The three-loop banana provably cannot produce one: anything assembled from pieces with complex multiplication inherits complex multiplication, and at equal mass Livné’s modularity theorem ties the surface’s weight-three part to a modular form with complex multiplication of its own. Details are in Bootstrapping elliptic and Calabi–Yau Feynman integrals.

The papers

Supplementary material

References

G. Passarino and M. J. G. Veltman, One-loop corrections for $e^+e^-$ annihilation into $\mu^+\mu^-$ in the Weinberg model, Nucl. Phys. B 160 (1979) 151the reduction of every one-loop amplitude to a small set of standard integrals
K. G. Chetyrkin and F. V. Tkachov, Integration by parts: the algorithm to calculate $\beta$-functions in 4 loops, Nucl. Phys. B 192 (1981) 159the integration-by-parts identities that relate the integrals of a family
S. Laporta, High-precision calculation of multiloop Feynman integrals by difference equations, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 15 (2000) 5087 [arXiv:hep-ph/0102033]the algorithm that organizes those identities into solvable linear systems
A. B. Goncharov, M. Spradlin, C. Vergu and A. Volovich, Classical polylogarithms for amplitudes and Wilson loops, Phys. Rev. Lett. 105 (2010) 151605 [arXiv:1006.5703]the symbol of a polylogarithmic function
J. M. Henn, Multiloop integrals in dimensional regularization made simple, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110 (2013) 251601 [arXiv:1304.1806]the canonical, $\varepsilon$-factorized form of the differential equations
V. A. Smirnov, Analytical result for dimensionally regularized massless on-shell double box, Phys. Lett. B 460 (1999) 397 [arXiv:hep-ph/9905323]the closed form of the massless double box, rederived here coefficient by coefficient
S. Caron-Huot and J. M. Henn, Iterative structure of finite loop integrals, JHEP 06 (2014) 114 [arXiv:1404.2922]the outer-mass double box on which the method was first tested
S. Laporta and E. Remiddi, Analytic treatment of the two-loop equal-mass sunrise graph, Nucl. Phys. B 704 (2005) 349 [arXiv:hep-ph/0406160]the analytic evaluation of the equal-mass sunrise on its elliptic curve
L. Adams, C. Bogner, A. Schweitzer and S. Weinzierl, The kite integral to all orders in terms of elliptic polylogarithms, J. Math. Phys. 57 (2016) 122302 [arXiv:1607.01571]the equal-mass kite in elliptic polylogarithms, one of the elliptic results rederived here
S. Pögel, X. Wang and S. Weinzierl, Taming Calabi–Yau Feynman integrals: the four-loop equal-mass banana integral, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130 (2023) 101601 [arXiv:2211.04292]the $\varepsilon$-factorized differential equation carried up to the Calabi–Yau banana
N. Schwanemann and S. Weinzierl, Electroweak double-box integrals for Møller scattering, SciPost Phys. 18 (2025) 172 [arXiv:2412.07522]the central-mass double box whose published result the recomputation here matches
X. Liu and Y.-Q. Ma, AMFlow: a Mathematica package for Feynman integrals computation via auxiliary mass flow, Comput. Phys. Commun. 283 (2023) 108565 [arXiv:2201.11669]the auxiliary-mass-flow method that supplies the high-precision values and the independent evaluations
S. Mizera and S. Telen, Landau discriminants, JHEP 08 (2022) 200 [arXiv:2109.08036]the singularities of a Feynman integral computed from the graph by algebraic geometry
H. S. Hannesdóttir, A. J. McLeod, M. D. Schwartz and C. Vergu, Applications of the Landau bootstrap, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) 085003 [arXiv:2410.02424]the Landau bootstrap, one of the two methods extended here, with the outer-mass double box as its worked example
O. Barrera, A. Dersy, R. Husain, M. D. Schwartz and X. Zhang, Analytic regression of Feynman integrals from high-precision numerical sampling, JHEP 01 (2026) 014 [arXiv:2507.17815]analytic regression, the other parent method, with the elliptic case left for later work
W.-J. He, R.-Y. Zhang, L. Han, Y. Jiang, Z. Li, X.-F. Wang, S.-X. Li, P.-F. Li and Q.-h. Wang, Two-loop planar master integrals for NNLO QCD corrections to W-pair production in quark-antiquark annihilation, JHEP 12 (2024) 136 [arXiv:2409.08879]the three planar branches of two-loop W-pair production with exact top-quark mass; the non-planar branch computed here was left open there

← back to the web summaries