Energy correlators (collider physics)
Energy correlators measure how the energy of a collider event is distributed in angle, and they are among the cleanest quantities QCD can predict. Frontier energy-correlator computations involve elliptic integrals, which BootLoops can compute.
Project pages: The hidden sunrise (two-point correlator at NNLO) · The four-point energy correlator
What an energy correlator measures
A quark or gluon knocked out of a high-energy collision turns into a jet, a narrow spray of particles. In 1978 C. Louis Basham, Lowell Brown, Stephen Ellis and Sherwin Love proposed a simple test of quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the theory of the strong force. Take every pair of final-state particles, weight it by the product of the two energies, and histogram the pairs in the angle $\chi$ between them. Averaged over many collisions, that histogram is the energy–energy correlator (EEC). It is largest at small angles, where both particles sit inside one jet, and again near 180 degrees, where they sit in opposite jets.

The energy–energy correlator, built up one collision at a time. Left, one collision inside a detector: particles fly out, mostly in two back-to-back jets and sometimes a third; the cells that catch them light up in proportion to their energy, and pairs of cells are picked out with the angle $\chi$ between them. Right, every pair of particles goes into a histogram in $\chi$ with weight equal to the product of the two energies. The dark bars are the current collision and the pale curve is the average over many collisions; that average, as a function of $\chi$, is the energy–energy correlator, largest where both particles sit inside one jet (collinear) or in opposite jets (back-to-back). (Animation drawn for this site from a toy event generator. It is not a QCD calculation or a figure from the papers.)
Written out, the EEC is an energy-weighted cross sectionthe rate at which collisions produce a given outcome, expressed as an effective target area; here each outcome is weighted by its particles’ energies,
$$\frac{d\sigma}{d\zeta}=\sum_{i,j}\int d\mathrm{LIPS}\;|\mathcal{M}|^2\,\frac{E_iE_j}{Q^2}\;\delta\left(\zeta-\frac{1-\cos\theta_{ij}}{2}\right).$$The sum runs over pairs of final-state particles $i,j$ with energies $E_i$, $E_j$ and angle $\theta_{ij}$ between them; $Q$ is the collision energy, $|\mathcal{M}|^2$ the squared amplitude for producing that final state, and $d\mathrm{LIPS}$ the integral over all allowed final momenta. The delta function picks out the pairs at the chosen angle, expressed through $\zeta=\tfrac12(1-\cos\chi)$, which runs from $0$ for touching cells to $1$ for cells back to back. Weighting by four energies instead of two gives the four-point correlator (E4C), a function of five independent angles that resolves the shape of a jet’s energy flow.
Energy correlators are among the simplest quantities one can both compute and measure at a collider: they are infrared finitefree of the divergences that arbitrarily soft or exactly parallel particles would otherwise produce, so the perturbative prediction is finite order by order, they need no jet-finding algorithm, and the energy weights suppress the low-energy debris that is hardest to predict. The two-point correlator was measured at the LEP electron–positron collider and has been used to determine the strong coupling constantthe single number that sets the strength of the strong force at a given energy; every perturbative QCD prediction is a power series in it. It has recently been re-extracted from archived events of LEP’s DELPHI experiment, and both it and its three-point relative are now measured inside jets at the Large Hadron Collider. Predictions for these correlators are computed order by order in the coupling: leading order (LO), next-to-leading order (NLO), then NNLOnext-to-next-to-leading order, the third term of the perturbative expansion in the coupling. New techniques for such calculations are often tried first in $\mathcal N=4$ super Yang–Mills theory, a highly symmetric relative of QCD in which the calculations are known to simplify.
Beyond polylogarithms
Both projects are about energy correlators that cannot be written in polylogarithmsiterated integrals of rational functions, the logarithm and dilogarithm being the simplest; the standard special functions of perturbative quantum field theory, the standard special functions of perturbation theory. Every earlier energy-correlator result can be written that way: the two-point correlator through NLO in QCD and, apart from one leftover integral, through NNLO in $\mathcal N=4$, and the three-point correlator at leading order. At NNLO in the two-point correlator, or already at leading order in the four-point one, new functions appear: the leftover NNLO piece lives on an elliptic curvea curve $y^2=Q(x)$ with $Q$ a cubic or quartic; its functions live on a torus and cannot be reduced to polylogarithms, and the four-point correlator at generic angles involves two elliptic curves and a genus-2 curve, a two-holed surface. For a decade such curves have been a recurring obstacle in computing multi-loop Feynman integralsthe integrals over the momenta of unobserved virtual particles that each Feynman diagram prescribes; evaluating them is the hard part of a precise prediction; here they turn up in quantities that experiments measure. Both calculations proceed the same way: identify the curve, work out which functions live on it, evaluate the answer in terms of them, and, where the theory is QCD, compare the prediction with data, as in the plot below.

The four-point correlator compared with collider data. The jets were recorded by the CMS experiment in 2011 and released through the CERN Open Data portal. Inside each jet an arrangement of four directions is fixed (the “tee” arrangement at relative size $\rho=0.4$) and the four-point correlator is measured as the angle $\phi$ that orients the fourth direction is varied. Points: how far the measured correlator sits above or below its average over $\phi$, from charged particles as the detector recorded them, with no correction for detector effects. Vertical bars combine the statistical uncertainty with one from how loosely the arrangement is matched in the data; horizontal bars mark the $\phi$ bins. Red curve: the leading-order QCD prediction for a 60:40 mix of quark and gluon jets, with nothing fit. Pale band: the spread between pure-quark and pure-gluon jets. The measured shape follows the curve. Of the three families of arrangements studied, the tee family is the best described; agreement worsens for larger arrangements that reach toward the edge of the jet, and the authors call the whole comparison a preliminary proof of principle. (Redrawn for this site from the middle panel of Figure 4 of the four-point paper.)
The two studies
The hidden sunrise in the energy-energy correlator. The 2019 calculation of the NNLO two-point correlator in $\mathcal N=4$ super Yang–Mills by Henn, Sokatchev, Yan and Zhiboedov left one integral unevaluated. Those authors had already noticed that the leftover piece involves the elliptic curve of the equal-mass sunrise integralthe two-loop Feynman integral in which three massive particle lines connect the same two points; drawn, it looks like a sun rising over the horizon, the first Feynman integral found to need elliptic functions. The identification is in fact exact: the curve in the correlator and the sunrise curve have identical $j$-invariantsa single number computed from an elliptic curve’s equation; two curves with the same j-invariant are the same curve in different coordinates and are therefore the same curve. Once the last piece is written in that curve’s modular formshighly symmetric functions attached to a family of elliptic curves; their series converge fast, which makes them easy to evaluate to many digits, it can be evaluated to high precision within seconds, and with it the complete correlator. A separate question is how much of the answer could instead have been bootstrappedfixed from the known singularities, symmetries and limiting behavior of the answer plus a few numerical values, instead of computing every integral directly from general requirements. Regularity and the known limits alone fix only 16% of the unknown coefficients; the rest require precise numerical values.

The complete two-point correlator in $\mathcal N=4$ super Yang–Mills with coupling $a=0.09$. Horizontal axis: the angle variable $\zeta$, from nearly collinear at the left to nearly back-to-back at the right, on a scale stretched to open up both ends. Vertical axis: the correlator multiplied by $\sqrt{\zeta(1-\zeta)}$, which tames its steep rise at the ends. Slate: leading order. Violet: through second order (NLO). Orange: through third order (NNLO), the order now complete. Across the broad middle of the range the three orders lie close together and the series settles quickly. Toward either end successive orders swing apart and the NLO curve even turns negative, the known sign that large logarithms there must be summed to all orders before the prediction can be trusted. (Redrawn for this site from Figure 2 of the paper.)
New mathematics and new physics in the four-point energy correlator. The shape dependence of the four-point correlator had not been worked out in QCD, and one jet study had used the $\mathcal N=4$ answer in its place. Computing the QCD correlator at leading order answers whether all of its singularities already appear in the $\mathcal N=4$ one, as an exact substitute would require. In the collinear limitthe regime in which all four measured directions lie close together inside a single jet, at the leading singular order, the QCD correlator for quark jets has no singularities beyond those of the supersymmetric theory, while the one for gluon jets does. At wide angles the genus-2 curve enters the QCD integrand too, in the channel where a second quark–antiquark pair is produced. Four-point curves extracted from CMS Open Data jets and archival DELPHI events follow the leading-order shapes, in a detector-level comparison that the authors call a preliminary proof of principle.
The papers
- The hidden sunrise in the energy-energy correlator (PDF) — Matthew D. Schwartz and Xiaoyuan Zhang.
- New mathematics and new physics in the four-point energy correlator — Matthew D. Schwartz and Xiaoyuan Zhang; in preparation.
Supplementary material
The evaluator written for the two-point calculation is described on the hidden-sunrise page. It documents its interface in its header, and its self-test compares its values with the authors’ independent evaluation of the original two-fold integral at four angles.
- eec-nnlo-evaluate.py — Python (mpmath): evaluates the elliptic remainder of the two-point NNLO correlator in the paper’s final form, $F_R(\zeta)=2F_{K_1}(\zeta)+P(\zeta)$: $P$ in harmonic polylogarithms up to weight five, $F_{K_1}$ from the Picard–Fuchs system as iterated Eisenstein integrals, at a rational angle $\zeta$ to any requested number of digits;
python3 eec-nnlo-evaluate.py --checkruns its 23 built-in checks: the $q$-expansions and the values of $q_0$ printed in the paper, seven harmonic polylogarithms against mpmath, and $F_R$ at four angles against the authors’ independent evaluation of the original two-fold integral;python3 eec-nnlo-evaluate.py 3/11 --digits 50returns $F_R(3/11)=0.4454321028\ldots$
References
| C. L. Basham, L. S. Brown, S. D. Ellis and S. T. Love, Energy Correlations in Electron-Positron Annihilation: Testing Quantum Chromodynamics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 41 (1978) 1585 | proposed the energy–energy correlator as a test of QCD |
| Z. Tulipánt, A. Kardos and G. Somogyi, Energy–energy correlation in electron–positron annihilation at NNLL + NNLO accuracy, Eur. Phys. J. C 77 (2017) 749 | precise two-point predictions for $e^+e^-$ collisions, used to determine the strong coupling |
| P. T. Komiske, I. Moult, J. Thaler and H. X. Zhu, Analyzing N-Point Energy Correlators inside Jets with CMS Open Data, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130 (2023) 051901 | multi-point energy correlators extracted from CMS Open Data jets |
| J. Zhang, T.-A. Sheng, Y.-C. Chen, H. Bossi, A. Badea, A. Baty, C. McGinn, Y.-J. Lee and Y. Chen, Analysis note: measurement of thrust and track energy-energy correlator in $e^+e^-$ collisions at 91.2 GeV with DELPHI open data, arXiv:2510.18762 (2025) | the two-point correlator re-extracted from archived DELPHI events |
| L. J. Dixon, M.-X. Luo, V. Shtabovenko, T.-Z. Yang and H. X. Zhu, Analytical Computation of Energy-Energy Correlation at Next-to-Leading Order in QCD, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 (2018) 102001 | the two-point correlator at NLO in QCD, in polylogarithms |
| J. M. Henn, E. Sokatchev, K. Yan and A. Zhiboedov, Energy-energy correlation in $\mathcal{N}=4$ super-Yang-Mills theory at next-to-next-to-leading order, Phys. Rev. D 100 (2019) 036010 | the NNLO two-point correlator in $\mathcal N=4$ with one integral left unevaluated |
| T.-Z. Yang and X. Zhang, Analytic computation of three-point energy correlator in QCD, JHEP 09 (2022) 006 | the three-point correlator at leading order in QCD, still polylogarithmic |
| D. Chicherin, I. Moult, E. Sokatchev, K. Yan and Y. Zhu, Collinear limit of the four-point energy correlator in N=4 supersymmetric Yang-Mills theory, Phys. Rev. D 110 (2024) L091901 | the collinear four-point correlator in $\mathcal N=4$, the answer that stood in for QCD |
| R. Ma, J. Gong, J. Lin, K. Yan, G. Yang and Y. Zhang, Differential equations for energy correlators in any angle, JHEP 02 (2026) 025 | reduced the $\mathcal N=4$ four-point correlator at generic angles to integrals with two elliptic curves and a genus-2 curve |
| M. Gonzalez, P. Harris, K. Lee, I. Moult and S. Rothman, Dissecting Parton Showers with Multi-Point Energy Correlators, arXiv:2607.07792 (2026) | the jet study that used the $\mathcal N=4$ four-point correlator in place of QCD |
| S. Bloch and P. Vanhove, The elliptic dilogarithm for the sunset graph, J. Number Theor. 148 (2015) 328 | the equal-mass sunrise on its elliptic curve, with the modular group $\Gamma_1(6)$ behind the NNLO formula |