The hidden sunrise in the energy-energy correlator (collider physics)

← Energy correlators

Energy correlators measure how the energy of a collider event is distributed in angle, and the two-point correlator can be predicted exactly, order by order in the coupling. At third order in the supersymmetric cousin of QCD, one integral had resisted evaluation since 2019; it lives on the elliptic curve of the sunrise diagram, and with that identification the whole answer can be written in closed form.

Energy flow at a fixed angle

When an electron and a positron annihilate at high energy, a spray of particles comes out in all directions. In the late 1970s Basham, Brown, Ellis and Love proposed a simple summary of such an event: take every pair of outgoing particles, weight the pair by the product of its two energies, and record the angle $\chi$ between them. Averaged over many collisions this gives a distribution in the angle, the energy–energy correlator or EEC. As an energy-weighted cross section,

$$\frac{d\sigma}{d\zeta}= \sum_{ij}\int d\text{LIPS}\; |\mathcal{M}|^2 \,\frac{E_iE_j}{Q^2}\; \delta\!\left(\zeta-\frac{1-\cos\theta_{ij}}{2}\right).$$

The sum runs over all pairs of final-state particles $i$ and $j$, with energies $E_i$, $E_j$ and relative angle $\theta_{ij}$; $Q$ is the total collision energy, $|\mathcal{M}|^2$ the squared quantum amplitude for that final state, and $d\text{LIPS}$ the integration over all allowed final-state momenta. The delta function keeps only pairs at the chosen angle, expressed through the variable $\zeta=(1-\cos\chi)/2$, which runs from 0 to 1. Nearly parallel pairs give $\zeta\to0$, the collinear limit; opposite pairs give $\zeta\to1$, the back-to-back limit.

The EEC is among the simplest observables in perturbative quantum chromodynamics (QCD), the theory of quarks and gluons. It is infrared finiteFree of the infinities that afflict most collider quantities when a particle is emitted with almost no energy or almost parallel to another particle., needs no jet algorithmA recipe for grouping an event’s particles into jets, the narrow sprays left by quarks and gluons; a prediction then depends on the recipe., compares directly with data, and has been used to measure the strong coupling. That simplicity also makes it a good place to study what kinds of functions an exact collider prediction is built from.

Exact results before this work

Predictions for the EEC come as a series in the coupling strength: leading order (LO), next-to-leading order (NLO), next-to-next-to-leading order (NNLO), each harder than the last. Alongside QCD, theorists work in $\mathcal{N}=4$ super-Yang–Mills theory, a far more symmetric relative that shares many perturbative features with QCD and is often used as a simpler model for developing techniques. In QCD the EEC is known analytically through NLO, for electron–positron annihilation (2018) and for Higgs-boson decays to hadrons (2019–2021). In $\mathcal{N}=4$ it is known one order further: at NLO since 2014, and at NNLO since the 2019 calculation of Henn, Sokatchev, Yan and Zhiboedov.

All the exact results through NLO are polylogarithmsThe logarithm, the dilogarithm $\mathrm{Li}_2$ and their generalizations: functions built by repeatedly integrating simple rational forms, one integration inside the next. The number of nested integrations is the weight; $\log$ has weight one, $\pi^2$ and $\mathrm{Li}_2$ weight two, $\zeta_3$ weight three. of weight up to three, a class with a well-developed algebra and public programs that evaluate its members fast and to high precision. The 2019 NNLO result almost fits in the same class. Its authors reduced the answer to harmonic polylogarithmsA standard basis for polylogarithms of one variable, labeled by strings of 0s, 1s and −1s, with fast public routines to evaluate them. of weight up to five plus one leftover: a finite two-fold integral of a rational kernel multiplying weight-three polylogarithms, left unevaluated. They also observed that the kernel is tied to the elliptic curve of the equal-mass sunrise integral. That leftover, written $F_R(\zeta)$ below, also has a closed form.

When polylogarithms run out

An integral stays polylogarithmic as long as every square root in its integrand can be removed by a change of variables. The square root of a quadratic polynomial always can be. The square root of a cubic or quartic $Q(x)$ with distinct roots cannot, and the equation $y^2=Q(x)$ then defines a new geometric object, an elliptic curveThe set of solutions of $y^2=Q(x)$ with $Q$ a cubic or quartic polynomial. Over the complex numbers its points form a surface with one hole, a torus. Integrals around the two independent cycles of the torus are its periods, the complete elliptic integrals; as the curve’s parameter varies they obey a second-order differential equation called the Picard–Fuchs equation.. Its basic integrals are elliptic integrals rather than logarithms, and the functions built on them lie outside the class of polylogarithms; the tools for handling such elliptic functions are far less developed. For energy correlators, elliptic functions first appear in the EEC at NNLO and in the four-point correlator at LO; the four-point case has a page of its own, the four-point correlator.

Feynman diagram of the two-loop sunrise integral: a horizontal line carrying momentum p enters from the left and ends at a vertex; three internal lines, each labeled m, the outer two curved and the middle one straight, connect that vertex to a second vertex on the right; a line carrying momentum p leaves the second vertex to the right.

The sunrise diagram. A particle of momentum $p$ enters from the left and splits into three virtual particles of the same mass $m$, the three internal lines, which recombine into one particle leaving on the right. The two-loop Feynman integral for this diagram, taken in two dimensions, is finite and depends only on the ratio $S/m^2$ with $S=p^2$. It is the first Feynman integral known to require elliptic functions, and its elliptic curve is the one hidden in the correlator. (The diagram of Eq. (23) of the paper.)

The two-loop sunrise diagram with three equal masses, drawn above, has been studied extensively, by Laporta and Remiddi, Adams, Bogner and Weinzierl, and Bloch and Vanhove, among others. Writing it in Feynman parametersAuxiliary variables that merge the denominators of a loop integral into a single polynomial, trading the integrals over momenta for integrals over a simplex. and completing a square exposes the square root of a quartic, which defines the sunrise curve. As the invariant mass $S=p^2$ flowing through the diagram varies, the curve changes shape, and it degenerates at exactly four values, $S/m^2=0,\,1,\,9,\,\infty$; the value $9m^2=(3m)^2$ is the threshold at which the three internal particles can all become real. All four degenerations are of one particular kind (the technical term is maximally unipotent). The family of curves traced out as $S$ varies is governed by a subgroup of the modular group called $\Gamma_1(6)$, whose natural functions are modular formsA torus is described, up to rescaling, by one complex number $\tau$, and changing $\tau$ by an element of the modular group $\mathrm{SL}(2,\mathbb{Z})$ gives back the same torus. Modular forms are functions of $\tau$ that transform in a prescribed way under the modular group or one of its subgroups, such as $\Gamma_1(6)$; they have power-series expansions in $q=e^{2\pi i\tau}$ with highly structured coefficients; the simplest examples are the Eisenstein series. The four degeneration points of the sunrise family are the four cusps of $\Gamma_1(6)$.. Work since the mid-2000s has made the sunrise’s periods, its modular parametrization and the iterated integrals of its modular forms explicit.

The same curve as the sunrise diagram

The first step is to reorganize $F_R$, whose kernel involves three quadratic polynomials in the inner integration variable $x$: one factors and yields only logarithms, while the other two, $D_1$ and $D_2$, have discriminantsA combination of a polynomial’s coefficients that vanishes exactly when two roots coincide; solving for the roots brings in its square root. that are not perfect squares and are the source of everything elliptic. A partial-fraction decomposition, organized by the Galois symmetry of the integrand (flipping the sign of either square root must change nothing), splits $F_R$ into three finite pieces: $F_{{\rm red}_1}$, free of square roots and therefore polylogarithmic, and two irreducible pieces $F_{K_1}$ and $F_{R_2}$ with one square root each. After the $x$ integration, the expression under each square root is a quartic in the outer variable $\bar z$. The first defines the curve

$$\mathcal{C}_\zeta:\qquad y^2\;=\;Q_1(\bar z)\;=\;\left(\bar z^{\,2}-\bar z+2\zeta^2-\zeta\right)^2+4\,\zeta^3(1-\zeta).$$

Each angle $\zeta$ thus comes with its own elliptic curve. Written this way $Q_1$ is a square plus a positive number whenever $0\lt\zeta\lt1$, so the integrand is real across the physical range, with all of its singularities on the boundary of the integration region. The second quartic, $Q_2$, looks different, but the Möbius map $w=\bar z/(\bar z-1)$ gives $Q_2(\bar z)=(\bar z-1)^4\,Q_1(w)$ and carries the integration measure of $F_{R_2}$ into that of $F_{K_1}$. The two irreducible pieces are integrals over one and the same curve along different paths. The coordinate-independent test of whether two elliptic curves coincide is to compare their $j$-invariantsA single number computed from the coefficients of the cubic or quartic that defines an elliptic curve. Two curves can be carried into each other by a change of coordinates (over the complex numbers) exactly when their $j$-invariants are equal. For a family of curves depending on a parameter, $j$ is a rational function of that parameter whose poles mark where the curve degenerates.. For $\mathcal{C}_\zeta$ it is

$$j(\zeta)\;=\;\frac{(1+2\zeta)^3\left(8\zeta^3-12\zeta^2+6\zeta+1\right)^3}{\zeta^6\,(1-\zeta)^2\,(1+8\zeta)}.$$

The poles of $j(\zeta)$ sit at the collinear and back-to-back points $\zeta=0$ and $\zeta=1$, at infinity, and at one more finite point, $\zeta=-1/8$, which lies outside the physical range and looks accidental. The sunrise’s $j$-invariant is a rational function of $S/m^2$ with poles at its four degeneration points, and substituting $S=m^2(\zeta-1)/\zeta$ into it reproduces the expression above identically in $\zeta$. The special points match one to one, $S/m^2=\infty,\,0,\,9,\,1$ against $\zeta=0,\,1,\,-1/8,\,\infty$, so the puzzling $\zeta=-1/8$ corresponds to the three-particle threshold $S=9m^2$. Physical angles map to negative $S/m^2$, the Euclidean region of the sunrise below every threshold, which is why nothing singular happens between the collinear limit at $S\to-\infty$ and the back-to-back limit at $S\to0$.

Sharing a curve does not make two integrals equal; how the two are related follows from differential equations. Differentiating $F_{K_1}$ twice in $\zeta$ produces one new two-fold integral, $S_0(\zeta)$, and the pair closes into a second-order system. The system is built on the sunrise’s Picard–Fuchs operator, $\zeta(\zeta-1)(8\zeta+1)\,\partial_\zeta^2+(24\zeta^2-14\zeta-1)\,\partial_\zeta+2(4\zeta-1)$, with $\partial_\zeta$ the derivative in $\zeta$. Because the system is second order, no geometry beyond an elliptic curve can appear. Running the same analysis on $F_{R_2}$ and subtracting shows that $\Delta=F_{R_2}-F_{K_1}$ is itself a polylogarithm, given in closed form. So $F_R=2F_{K_1}+P(\zeta)$ with $P$ polylogarithmic, and one elliptic function remains to be found.

The finished formula

The polylogarithmic part $P(\zeta)$ comes from doing both integrations directly with HyperInt, Erik Panzer’s program for such integrals. It fills about a page: harmonic polylogarithms of weight up to five whose letters (the elementary arguments fed into the nested integrations) are only $\zeta$ and $1-\zeta$, with rational-function coefficients and the constants $\pi^2$, $\zeta_3$, $\pi^4$, $\zeta_5$ and $\pi^2\zeta_3$.

The elliptic part is solved by passing to a modular frame. The Picard–Fuchs operator has a power-series solution at the collinear point, the period $\psi_1(\zeta)=1-2\zeta+10\zeta^2-56\zeta^3+\dots$, whose coefficients are, up to sign, the Franel numbers $\sum_k\binom{n}{k}^3$. Exponentiating the ratio of its two solutions gives a new variable $q=\zeta-3\zeta^2+15\zeta^3-\dots$, and conversely $\zeta$ and $\psi_1$, regarded as functions of $q$, are modular objects for $\Gamma_1(6)$, quotients of Dedekind eta functions. In this frame the equation for $S_0$ becomes two successive integrations in $\log q$, and the answer is a combination of iterated integralsIntegrals nested one inside the next, each running up to the variable of the one outside it; polylogarithms are the simplest examples. $I(f_1,\dots,f_n;q)$ whose kernels $f_i$ are modular forms; integrals of this kind are called iterated Eisenstein integrals. Apart from a trivial constant kernel, only four others occur: $d\log\zeta$ and $-d\log(1-\zeta)$ rewritten in $q$, called $\omega_0$ and $\omega_1$, which the polylogarithms already use, and two new ones of modular weight three, $\psi_1\omega_0$ and $\zeta\psi_1\omega_0$, through which the curve enters. The function $S_0/\psi_1$ comes out as three boundary terms plus thirteen such iterated integrals of length up to five, each with a rational coefficient, in a few cases times $\pi^2$ or $\zeta_3$ (Eq. (61) of the paper).

The complete correlator is then $F_{\rm NNLO}=F_{\rm P}+F_{\rm E}$. Here $F_{\rm P}$ gathers all the harmonic polylogarithms, of argument $\sqrt{\zeta}$ and weight up to five. The elliptic part is $F_{\rm E}=2A\,S_0/\psi_1+2B\,\theta(S_0/\psi_1)$, with $\theta=q\,d/dq$ and coefficients $A$ and $B$ built from rational functions of $\zeta$, the period $\psi_1$ and its derivative. Every ingredient is explicit and cheap to evaluate: find the $q_0$ for the chosen angle, expand the kernels as integer $q$-series, and build the iterated integrals from the inside out as truncated series with rational coefficients, rounding only at the end. The number of correct digits grows linearly with the truncation order $N$, roughly as $D\simeq N\log_{10}(1/q_0)-3$; fifty digits take about 75 terms at $\zeta_0=3/11$ and about 106 at $\zeta_0=1/2$. This truncated-series method is the standard one for iterated integrals of modular forms and is also implemented in the GiNaC library, against which the implementation used here was checked. With it the NNLO distribution comes out to high precision within seconds.

Checks at the two ends

The closed form has been expanded to third order at both ends of the angular range. In the collinear limit the expansion begins $\zeta\left[\tfrac12\log^2\zeta+\left(-5+\tfrac{\pi^2}{3}-\zeta_3\right)\log\zeta+\dots\right]$, and every constant in it is a zeta value. The back-to-back expansion begins $-\tfrac18\log^5(1-\zeta)$; its subleading terms need $\log2$, polylogarithms at one half, and one new constant, $S_0(1)\approx13.8046$, the elliptic function at the second cusp, which involves a sixth root of unity. In each limit the leading terms are fixed independently by a general theory of that limit: the light-ray operator product expansionA method that predicts the small-angle behavior of energy correlators from operators smeared along the light-like paths of the outgoing particles. on the collinear side and Sudakov resummationA technique that sums the dominant logarithms from soft and collinear radiation at every order at once, instead of one order at a time. on the back-to-back side.

Log-scale plot of the square root of zeta times one minus zeta, times d sigma d zeta, against zeta on a horizontal axis stretched logarithmically toward both ends, from ten to the minus five through 0.5 to one minus ten to the minus five; vertical axis from about 1 to ten to the seventh. A solid blue curve labeled delta NNLO falls in a straight line from about ten to the four at the left edge to a minimum near 10 around zeta of 0.6, then rises steeply to several times ten to the six at the right edge. An orange dashed curve labeled Collinear expansion lies on top of the blue curve from the left edge to about zeta of 0.5 and then falls below it. A green dashed curve labeled Back-to-back expansion lies on top of the blue curve from the right edge down to about one minus zeta of 0.2 and then drops away sharply.

The third-order term of the correlator on its own (solid blue, labeled $\delta$NNLO), multiplied by $\sqrt{\zeta(1-\zeta)}$, against the angle variable $\zeta$. The horizontal axis is stretched logarithmically toward both ends, so the collinear region on the left and the back-to-back region on the right each span several decades. Orange dashes: the collinear expansion through order $\zeta^3$. Green dashes: the back-to-back expansion through order $(1-\zeta)^2$. Each expansion lies on the exact curve over many decades on its own side and peels away only near the middle; the collinear one stays reliable out to $\zeta\approx0.5$. (Figure 1 of the paper.)

The figure above compares each expansion with the exact curve over ten decades of the stretched $\zeta$ axis; the one below shows how the perturbative series behaves, with the correlator summed through LO, NLO and NNLO at a sample coupling. In the bulk of the range the orders sit close together and fixed order is reliable. Toward either endpoint large logarithms of $\zeta$ or $1-\zeta$ take over, the orders pull apart, and the NLO curve even turns negative near $1-\zeta\sim10^{-2}$. There the logarithms must be resummed to all orders, which for the EEC has been done to high accuracy in both limits; fixed-order results such as this one supply the ingredients.

Line plot of the square root of zeta times one minus zeta, times d sigma d zeta, against zeta on a horizontal axis stretched logarithmically toward both ends, from ten to the minus four through 0.5 to one minus ten to the minus three; vertical axis from minus one to four. Three curves labeled LO (green), NLO (blue) and NNLO (red), with the label Coupling a = 0.09. In the middle of the range all three lie close together near 0.1. Toward the collinear end the green curve rises steeply to 4 and the red to about 2.8, while the blue curve stays near 0.3 and bends down toward zero at the left edge. Toward the back-to-back end the green and red curves rise steeply while the blue curve turns down and crosses below zero near one minus zeta of ten to the minus two.

The correlator in $\mathcal{N}=4$ super-Yang–Mills at leading order (green), through NLO (blue) and through NNLO (red) for a sample coupling $a=0.09$, multiplied by $\sqrt{\zeta(1-\zeta)}$ and drawn on the same stretched axis. The three curves agree closely across the middle of the range. Near both endpoints large logarithms drive them apart, and the NLO curve drops below zero near $1-\zeta\sim10^{-2}$, the sign that resummation is required there. (Figure 2 of the paper.)

A first look at a bootstrap, and the outlook for QCD

With the closed form known, one can ask how much of it could have been written down without doing the integrals, from the possible singularities, the curve and the known limits alone. Such bootstraps have fixed whole scattering amplitudes in planar $\mathcal{N}=4$, where the unknown coefficients are pure numbers; here they are rational functions of $\zeta$, and far more numerous. The polylogarithmic letters, derived from the integrand, are $\zeta$, $1-\zeta$ and $(1-\sqrt{\zeta})/(1+\sqrt{\zeta})$; on the elliptic side the curve, its Picard–Fuchs operator and the positions of the physical singularities allow only six kernels, so the space of candidate functions is finite, which is far from automatic.

At NLO the ansatzA trial form for the answer, here a list of allowed functions times unknown coefficients, pinned down by conditions the true answer must meet. has 206 rational parameters, and 76 of them are fixed by physical requirements: regularity at the endpoints, the known leading terms, a sum ruleAn exact value for the distribution integrated over all angles, fixed because the energies of all outgoing particles add up to the collision energy.. The other 130 are fixed by fitting 126 high-precision values, and the result agrees term by term with the 2014 calculation. At NNLO the joint ansatz has 2336 parameters, and as a robustness test its elliptic part is written without assuming in advance which six kernels are allowed. The physical requirements fix 373, merging parameters that enter only in fixed combinations removes 113 more, and the remaining 1850 are recovered in one step by lattice reductionAn algorithm that finds unexpectedly short integer combinations of given vectors; fed high-precision values, it exposes the exact rational numbers behind them., an integer-relation method, run with the program Flatter. That step succeeds from 150 values at 350 digits (119.5 CPU hours), and equally from 300 values at 270 digits, 600 at 225 or 1200 at 205 (50.4, 56.1 and 62.1 CPU hours). The recovered answer uses only the six kernels. With more sample points fewer digits per point are needed, but an information count of the sample set indicates that this gain levels off near 200 digits per point, and that at 100 digits or fewer no number of points up to 2400 would suffice.

The bootstrap test carries two caveats. First, its high-precision values were generated from the analytic answer itself, whereas a genuine bootstrap would need an independent numerical evaluator of the EEC. Second, physical constraints alone fixed only 16% of the NNLO parameters and about 80% came from the numerical data, so either new consistency conditions must be found or precise numerics must do most of the work, as they did here.

As for QCD, nothing specific to the supersymmetric theory fixed the space of elliptic functions: it followed from the curve and its modular group, both of which can be read off from the integrand alone, and the QCD integrand at this order is known even though its integrals are not. The same analysis should therefore give the elliptic letters and function space of the QCD answer in advance, and although a complete bootstrap of the NNLO correlator in QCD remains difficult, that knowledge could bypass steps of a direct calculation. The numerical method carries over unchanged: a QCD result written in iterated Eisenstein integrals could be evaluated just as fast, and to the high precision that comparisons with collider data require.

The paper

The overview and the companion four-point work are on the Energy correlators page and the four-point page.

Supplementary material

The script below evaluates the closed form by the truncated $q$-series method described above, with $\zeta$, $\psi_1$ and the kernels as exact rational $q$-series and every iterated integral, the harmonic polylogarithms included, built from the inside out and rounded only at the end; the number of terms follows the paper’s digit estimate. Its header documents the interface, and the self-test takes a few seconds on one core.

References

C. L. Basham, L. S. Brown, S. D. Ellis and S. T. Love, Energy correlations in electron-positron annihilation: testing QCD, Phys. Rev. Lett. 41 (1978) 1585proposed the energy–energy correlator as a test of QCD
A. V. Belitsky, S. Hohenegger, G. P. Korchemsky, E. Sokatchev and A. Zhiboedov, Energy-energy correlations in $\mathcal{N}=4$ supersymmetric Yang–Mills theory, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112 (2014) 071601the NLO correlator in $\mathcal{N}=4$, which the NLO bootstrap test reproduces term by term
L. J. Dixon, M.-X. Luo, V. Shtabovenko, T.-Z. Yang and H. X. Zhu, Analytical computation of energy-energy correlation at next-to-leading order in QCD, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 (2018) 102001the analytic NLO correlator in QCD for electron–positron annihilation
M.-X. Luo, V. Shtabovenko, T.-Z. Yang and H. X. Zhu, Analytic next-to-leading order calculation of energy-energy correlation in gluon-initiated Higgs decays, JHEP 06 (2019) 037the analytic NLO correlator for Higgs-boson decays to gluons
J. Gao, V. Shtabovenko and T.-Z. Yang, Energy-energy correlation in hadronic Higgs decays: analytic results and phenomenology at NLO, JHEP 02 (2021) 210the analytic NLO correlator for Higgs-boson decays to hadrons, the 2021 result mentioned above
J. M. Henn, E. Sokatchev, K. Yan and A. Zhiboedov, Energy-energy correlation in $\mathcal{N}=4$ super Yang–Mills theory at next-to-next-to-leading order, Phys. Rev. D 100 (2019) 036010the NNLO correlator with one two-fold integral left unevaluated; the starting point
E. Remiddi and J. A. M. Vermaseren, Harmonic polylogarithms, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 15 (2000) 725introduced the harmonic polylogarithms in which the polylogarithmic part of the correlator is written
A. Sabry, Fourth order spectral functions for the electron propagator, Nucl. Phys. 33 (1962) 401where the equal-mass sunrise integral, and with it elliptic integrals, first entered a Feynman-diagram calculation
S. Laporta and E. Remiddi, Analytic treatment of the two loop equal mass sunrise graph, Nucl. Phys. B 704 (2005) 349the differential equation and analytic treatment of the equal-mass sunrise
L. Adams, C. Bogner and S. Weinzierl, The two-loop sunrise graph with arbitrary masses, J. Math. Phys. 54 (2013) 052303the sunrise in two dimensions for arbitrary masses, solved through its second-order differential equation
S. Bloch and P. Vanhove, The elliptic dilogarithm for the sunset graph, J. Number Theor. 148 (2015) 328the equal-mass sunrise as an elliptic dilogarithm and its $\Gamma_1(6)$ modular structure
L. Adams and S. Weinzierl, Feynman integrals and iterated integrals of modular forms, Commun. Num. Theor. Phys. 12 (2018) 193the sunrise family in iterated integrals of modular forms, the function class of the elliptic part
M. Walden and S. Weinzierl, Numerical evaluation of iterated integrals related to elliptic Feynman integrals, Comput. Phys. Commun. 265 (2021) 108020the truncated-series evaluation of such iterated integrals in GiNaC, against which the authors checked their implementation
E. Panzer, Algorithms for the symbolic integration of hyperlogarithms with applications to Feynman integrals, Comput. Phys. Commun. 188 (2015) 148the program HyperInt, used for the polylogarithmic part
D. Chicherin, J. Henn and V. Mitev, Bootstrapping pentagon functions, JHEP 05 (2018) 164one of the Landau (Feynman-integral) bootstrap calculations the introduction cites, the approach the paper’s own bootstrap study follows
O. Barrera, A. Dersy, R. Husain, M. D. Schwartz and X. Zhang, Analytic regression of Feynman integrals from high-precision numerical sampling, arXiv:2507.17815 (2025)lattice reduction from numerical samples, the method of the bootstrap test
K. Ryan and N. Heninger, Fast practical lattice reduction through iterated compression, in Advances in Cryptology – CRYPTO 2023, Lecture Notes in Computer Science (Springer, 2023) 3the lattice-reduction program Flatter, used to recover the NNLO coefficients

← Energy correlators