Flux vacua (string theory)

← String theory

In string theory the extra dimensions are curled up into a small compact space whose shape is fixed by fluxes, higher-dimensional versions of magnetic flux that come in integer units. Since the fluxes are integers, finding and counting vacua is partly a problem about integer lattices, and parts of it can be solved exactly rather than numerically. Three examples are worked out here: a proven lower bound on the flux needed to stabilize K3×K3, the lowest-charge vacuum in one sector of another Calabi–Yau, and the KKLT benchmark value of $W_0$ to 140 certified digits.

Flux vacua and the landscape

Superstring theory is consistent only in ten spacetime dimensions, and M-theory, which contains the five string theories as limits, has eleven. We observe four. The remaining six or seven must be curled into a compact space far smaller than any distance yet probed, noticeable only through the particles and couplings it leaves behind in four dimensions.

The compact space must solve the higher-dimensional equations of motion, which away from sources are the vacuum Einstein equations, so it has to be Ricci-flat. If some supersymmetry survives (which keeps the solution stable and the four-dimensional theory calculable), the space must also be Kählera complex manifold, one covered by holomorphic coordinate patches, whose metric is compatible with those coordinates, so that lengths and the complex structure are preserved together under parallel transport, meaning a complex manifold whose metric respects the complex coordinates. Ricci-flatness and the Kähler condition together force special holonomy: a vector carried around any closed loop returns rotated only by a special unitary matrix, one in $SU(n)$ for a space of $n$ complex dimensions. A compact Kähler space with a Ricci-flat metric is by definition a Calabi–Yau manifold. A Calabi–Yau $n$-fold has $n$ complex and $2n$ real dimensions: threefolds hide the six extra dimensions of the superstring, and the twofolds other than the flat four-torus are the K3 surfaces.

Two of the three results below concern M-theory on a Calabi–Yau fourfold, eight real dimensions, which leaves three large dimensions rather than four. That setting still describes a four-dimensional world, through a duality. When the fourfold is a family of small two-tori over a six-dimensional base, M-theory on it is equivalent to type IIB string theory on that base (the F-theory description), and the fourth large dimension opens up as the tori shrink. The third result is stated directly in type IIB.

Each Calabi–Yau space comes in a continuous family, and the parameters of the family, its modulithe continuous parameters of a family of compact spaces: the overall size, the sizes of internal cycles, and the parameters of the complex structure; unless something fixes them they drift, and the four-dimensional physics drifts with them, are its sizes (Kähler moduli) and the parameters of its complex structure, roughly its angles (complex-structure modulithe parameters that deform a Calabi–Yau space as a complex manifold while keeping it Calabi–Yau; these are the moduli that fluxes fix; a fourfold has $h^{3,1}$ of them, one of the Hodge numbers fixed by its topology). Nothing in the classical equations selects one member of the family, so each modulus becomes a massless scalar field in four dimensions with no potential, which would mediate a long-range force competing with gravity and let the constants of nature drift. None of this is observed, so the moduli need a potential that fixes them.

The best-understood source of such a potential is flux. String theory and M-theory contain analogs of the electromagnetic field strength with more indices, in M-theory a four-form $G$. A compact space has closed cyclesclosed submanifolds that wrap a hole of the space and cannot be shrunk to a point, like the two independent circles on a torus; a four-form flux is integrated over four-dimensional cycles, submanifolds that wrap its holes the way the two circles of a torus do, and a field strength can have a nonzero integral over such a cycle with no source anywhere, because the cycle is not the boundary of any region. The argument Dirac applied to the flux around a magnetic monopole then makes each such integral a whole number. A flux is a choice of these integers, one per cycle. The energy stored in the flux depends on the shape of the space it threads, so flux gives the moduli a potential, whose minima fix the complex-structure moduli. A flux vacuum is a set of these integers together with the shape they hold in place.

The flux integers cannot be chosen freely: flux carries the same charge as M-theory’s membranes (M2-branes), and on a compact space Gauss’s law leaves field lines nowhere to end. The total charge must therefore cancel against a fixed contribution from the curvature of the space, $\chi(X)/24$ for a fourfold $X$ of Euler number $\chi(X)$. This tadpole conditioncharge conservation on the compact space: flux charge plus the number of membranes equals a fixed topological number of the geometry, $\chi/24$ for a fourfold; the name comes from the one-point (tadpole) diagram whose cancellation it expresses caps the flux charge at a topological number, the budget, so whether the charge needed to fix every modulus fits within the budget is a definite question for each geometry. The set of candidate vacua on all such spaces is the string landscape, infinite but discrete.

For M-theory on a fourfold $X$ with flux $G$ these conditions read

$$W(z)=\int_X G\wedge\Omega(z)\,,\qquad D_I W=0\,,\qquad N_{\rm flux}=\tfrac12\int_X G\wedge G\;\le\;\frac{\chi(X)}{24}\,.$$

Here $\Omega$ is the holomorphic four-formthe nowhere-vanishing $(4,0)$-form that every Calabi–Yau fourfold carries, unique up to an overall factor; its existence is equivalent to the holonomy lying in $SU(4)$, and its integrals over the four-cycles are the periods, which every Calabi–Yau fourfold carries and which is unique up to normalization. It depends on the complex-structure moduli $z$, and its integrals over the cycles, the periodsthe integrals of $\Omega$ over a basis of integer cycles: transcendental functions of the moduli that satisfy a linear differential equation, the Picard–Fuchs equation, and determine $W$ for every flux at once, are transcendental functions of $z$ computed from a linear differential equation they satisfy, the Picard–Fuchs equation. Since $G$ is one integer per cycle, $W$ is an integer combination of periods, the superpotentialthe single holomorphic function of the moduli, written down by Gukov, Vafa and Witten in 1999, that encodes the flux-induced potential in four-dimensional supergravity; its critical points are the candidate vacua of a given flux of Gukov, Vafa and Witten. The middle condition, one covariant derivative $D_I$ per modulus, asks for a critical point of $W$, where the flux holds the shape fixed; the last is the tadpole condition turned into a bound on the flux charge $N_{\rm flux}$, since the number of membranes cannot be negative. In what follows a vacuum always means a solution of these classical equations. Whether such a solution survives in the full string theory, with the sizes also fixed and with or without a positive cosmological constant, is a separate and debated question not addressed here.

The Tadpole Conjecture

The refined Tadpole Conjecture of Bena, Blåbäck, Graña and Lüst (2020) says that on a fourfold with many complex-structure moduli a flux stabilizing all $h^{3,1}$ of them at a generic point has charge $N_{\rm flux}\gt\alpha\,h^{3,1}$ with $\alpha\gt 1/3$. The budget grows more slowly than that with $h^{3,1}$, so if the conjecture holds, fluxes within the budget fix every modulus only at special points, of enhanced symmetry or degenerate geometry.

The conjecture’s primary example was M-theory on K3×K3, the product of two K3 surfaces and so a fourfold, with budget exactly 24; there the vacuum conditions become statements about integer matrices. A numerical search found no fully stabilizing flux of charge 24 or less; the smallest charge it reached was 25, with no proof that 25 is the minimum. Later tests on other geometries gave evidence on both sides. Of the results below only those on K3×K3 bear on the conjecture, and only on its founding example rather than on the many-moduli regime in which it is posed.

Two exact tools

The first tool is the genus theorythe part of the arithmetic of quadratic forms that sorts integer lattices into finite families (genera) and contains the mass formula, which fixes a weighted count of each family in advance of integral quadratic forms. The fluxes on a geometry form a lattice, integer points with an integer-valued inner product, and the charge of a flux is half its norm, the inner product of the flux with itself. Two lattices related by an integer change of basis count as one class. Two that merely agree over the real numbers and in arithmetic modulo every prime power belong to the same genus, and a genus contains only finitely many classes. The Smith–Minkowski–Siegel mass formula gives in advance, from that local data alone, the sum of $1/|\mathrm{Aut}\,L|$ over the classes $L$ of a genus, where $|\mathrm{Aut}\,L|$ is the number of symmetries of $L$. Classes can then be generated one from another by Kneser’s neighbor construction, and the list is proven complete the moment the sum is reached. A roota lattice vector of the shortest nonzero length an even lattice allows (norm 2); on a K3 surface a root orthogonal to the period plane signals an orbifold singularity and an enhanced gauge symmetry is a vector of norm 2, the shortest nonzero length possible in a lattice all of whose norms are even (an even lattice); the K3×K3 argument below turns on whether certain lattices contain roots.

The second tool is interval arithmetic, the machinery of computer-assisted proof. Every real number is carried as a ball, a midpoint with a radius guaranteed to contain the true value; each operation rounds the radius outward, and each truncated period series comes with a proven bound on its tail. A test due to Krawczyk (1969) turns a numerical candidate into a theorem: take a small box around the candidate solution, apply one Newton-type step to the whole box in interval arithmetic, and if the image lies strictly inside the original box, the box contains exactly one zero of the equations. In the results below every real number is such a ball, every integer is exact, and any discrete statement that is not proven is reported as open.

K3×K3: a theorem on one stratum

The two-cycles of a K3 surface, with the intersection number of two cycles as inner product, form a lattice $\Gamma$ of rank 22, even and unimodulareven: every lattice vector has even norm; unimodular: the Gram determinant is ±1, so the lattice coincides with its dual, of signature $(3,19)$: three directions of positive norm, nineteen of negative. The shape of the surface is recorded by a positive 3-plane in the real span of $\Gamma$, its period plane. A four-cycle on K3×K3 can be taken to be a two-cycle on each factor, so a flux, one integer per four-cycle, is a $22\times 22$ integer matrix coupling the lattice $\Gamma$ of one factor to that of the other. Its charge is half the trace of a symmetric operator $S$ on $\Gamma$ built from the matrix, and the budget is 24. Full stabilization is taken in its weakest reasonable sense, so that the bounds hold under any stronger reading: the vacuum must be isolated, and no root of $\Gamma$ may be orthogonal to either period plane (the smoothness clause). A root there would put that K3 surface at an orbifolda point where the space looks like flat space divided by a finite rotation group, as at the tip of a cone; extra massless gauge bosons appear there point, a cone-like singularity with extra massless gauge bosons, the non-generic situation the conjecture sets aside. This definition and three standard assumptions (the supergravity dictionary between fluxes and vacua, integer flux quantization, no anti-membranes) make up the hypotheses (H1)–(H4).

Each flux has a support, the sublattice of $\Gamma$ it actually uses on each factor, and fluxes are sorted into strata by the signature $(p,q)$ of their support. A vacuum of a given flux is isolated exactly when every eigenspace of $S$, its kernel included, has a definite sign. For 57 of the 80 possible signatures, gray in the figure below, that criterion alone excludes every flux: the part of $\Gamma$ orthogonal to the support lies in the kernel of $S$ and, for those signatures, contains directions of both signs.

A grid of cells, four rows labeled p = 0 to 3 from bottom to top and twenty columns labeled q = 0 to 19 left to right, one cell per signature (p,q) of the flux support on K3 times K3. Fifty-seven cells (rows p = 0, 1, 2 across columns q = 0 to 18) are shaded gray: excluded structurally, kernel indefinite, no isolated vacuum. The cell at p = 3, q = 0 is black: enumerated, every one of 412,531 in-budget candidates excluded. The rest of the p = 3 row and the cells at q = 19, p = 1 and 2 are white with outlines: enumeration proven finite, not run. The cell at p = 0, q = 19 has a bold violet outline with an arrow labeled W512, W512 prime, W1024 lie in this cell: the open definite rank-19 stratum. The cell at p = 3, q = 19 carries an orange dot labeled: the charge-22 flux has support (3,19). A legend above the grid states these keys.

Every stratum of flux support on K3×K3, one cell per signature $(p,q)$. Gray: the 57 strata excluded by the kernel argument; black, at $(3,0)$: the finite stratum, whose 412,531 in-budget candidates are all enumerated and excluded; thin outline: strata proven finite but not enumerated, with the orange dot at $(3,19)$ marking the charge-22 flux; bold violet, at $(0,19)$: the open definite stratum containing the root-free lattices $W_{512}$, $W_{512}'$, $W_{1024}$ described below. (Redrawn from Figure 1 of the paper.)

The black cell, support of rank at most three, is a finite problem: 412,531 candidate fluxes within the budget. For each, the part of $\Gamma$ orthogonal to the support is a definite rank-19 lattice of small determinant, and a root there violates the smoothness clause. Most candidates fall to a packing argument: a root-free rank-19 lattice of such small determinant would pack spheres more densely than the Cohn–Elkies bound permits. For the rest, every class of each remaining genus is proven to contain a root without listing the classes. The argument uses the Niemeier lattices, the 24 even unimodular lattices in dimension 24, whose root systems are completely classified. A root-free rank-19 class glued to a suitable rank-5 companion lattice would form one of them, and the rigid shape of a Niemeier root system then dictates how its roots project onto the companion. The possible companions are enumerated, the mass formula proves that list complete, and for each one an exact computation in rational numbers shows that no such projection is consistent. The conclusion (Theorem 3.4) is that under (H1)–(H4) every fully stabilizing flux on K3×K3 whose support has rank at most three carries $N_{\rm flux}\ge 25$: one unit more than the budget of 24, and the value at which the numerical searches had stopped.

At higher support rank the bound fails: an explicit flux of charge 22 and support rank 22 meets every stabilization condition, with two membranes making up the rest of the budget. Its vacuum is a smooth point held in place by an order-66 symmetry of the lattice, the kind of special locus Lüst and Wiesner anticipated; lattice and symmetry together match the cohomology lattice of a K3 surface found by Kondō, acted on by its automorphism of order 66. The conjecture’s founding prediction, that no flux within the budget fully stabilizes K3×K3, is therefore false under (H1)–(H4) off the rank-three stratum.

The definite stratum, the bold cell $(0,19)$, remains open. There an in-budget fully stabilizing flux would be a pair of root-free rank-19 lattices joined by an integer flux matrix $M$. Three root-free lattices pass every stabilization condition, $W_{512}$, $W_{512}'$ and $W_{1024}$, named by determinant, with proven charge bounds: at least 25 on any pair involving $W_{1024}$, and at least 24, the budget itself, on the others. Whether 24 is attained comes down to one equation in integers:

$$\mathrm{tr}\!\left(M\,W_B\,M^{\mathsf T}\,W_A\right)=48\,,\qquad M\in M_{19}(\mathbb{Z})\,,\ \det M\neq 0\,,\qquad W_A,W_B\in\{W_{512},W_{512}'\}\,.$$

Here $W_A$ and $W_B$ are the Gram matrices (tables of inner products of basis vectors) of the two lattices, $M$ is any $19\times19$ integer matrix of nonzero determinant, and the trace equals twice the charge. The equation is a finite problem about integer matrices with no physics left in it, and it is unsolved; so is the rest of the stratum, where seven further root-free lattices are known. None of this reaches the many-moduli regime in which the Tadpole Conjecture is actually posed; the two tools need only a flux lattice and a Picard–Fuchs system as input, but whether they stay practical at that scale is untested.

The Hulek–Verrill fourfold: the first vacuum

The second geometry is a Calabi–Yau fourfold constructed by the mathematicians Hulek and Verrill, with six complex-structure moduli and budget 30. In the flux sector invariant under the symmetry $S_6$ permuting the moduli, a flux is five integers $g=(g_1,\ldots,g_5)$ whose charge is a quadratic form in them. The smallest value the form takes is 1, on 626 inequivalent fluxes in the range studied below, so nothing in the lattice by itself forbids a vacuum of charge 1. On the symmetric slice, where all six moduli equal one value $\varphi$, a single equation decides whether a given flux has a vacuum: $\sum_a u_a A_a(\varphi)=0$, with integers $u_a$ fixed by the flux and five transcendental functions $A_a$ built from the periods.

The functions $A_a$ are computed in ball arithmetic from the slice’s Picard–Fuchs equation on a small box $R$ of values of $\varphi$. The table of enclosures does not depend on the flux, so one table serves every flux of charge up to 30 with components below a fixed cut. Within that range and box, no flux of charge 3 or less has a critical point of its superpotential, and the charge-4 flux $g=(-1,0,0,0,-3)$ has one, at $\varphi=0.0172802\ldots$, inside a Krawczyk ball of radius below $10^{-22}$ that contains no other (Proposition 4.1). So the first vacuum there has charge 4, three units above the lattice minimum.

Bar chart. Horizontal axis: flux charge N_flux from 1 to 30. Vertical axis: number of vacua found in the modulus box R, 0 to 6. A shaded band covers charges 1 to 3 with the annotation: the lattice allows fluxes here, 626 candidate classes at charge 1 alone, but none has a vacuum in the box. Bars of height 2 at charges 4 and 5, the first annotated: first vacuum in the box, charge 4, flux g = (-1,0,0,0,-3), proven to exist. Bars of height 6 at charges 16, 18, 20 and 22. All other charges have no bar. A note at mid right reads: 28 vacua in all among 58,388 flux classes of charge 1 to 30; vacua of charge 3 and 2 exist just outside the box.

Vacua found in the box $R$ at each flux charge, from the enumeration of all 58,388 flux classes of charge 1 through 30 in the range. Twenty-eight are found (bars), none of them at charges 1–3 (shaded band) although the lattice admits fluxes there; proven vacua of charge 3 and 2 lie just beyond the edge of the box. (Chart drawn for this page from the counts in Section 4.3 of the paper.)

Proposition 4.1 holds only inside the box and the range. Just past the box’s upper edge the charge-3 flux $(1,0,0,0,2)$ and the charge-2 flux $(1,0,0,0,1)$ have proven vacua, so over the whole slice the first vacuum lies at most one unit above the minimum the lattice allows. A charge-1 vacuum at a smooth point of the slice is neither found nor ruled out; at the conifold pointthe value of the modulus at which one cycle of the geometry shrinks to zero size, making the space singular and the period equation degenerate $\varphi=1/36$, where a cycle shrinks and the equation degenerates, a charge-1 solution with $W=0$ is known. Every period evaluation here assumes that the known fifth-order Picard–Fuchs operator annihilates all five periods of the sector (hypothesis (O)), which is a theorem of Verrill for the fundamental period and is taken from Jockers, Kotlewski and Kuusela for the other four. The full six-parameter flux family is untreated.

The KKLT benchmark number

The KKLT scenario of Kachru, Kallosh, Linde and Trivedi (2003) is the best-known recipe for a string vacuum with every modulus fixed and a small positive cosmological constant. It is set in type IIB string theory on a six-dimensional Calabi–Yau orientifolda compact space divided by a reflection symmetry combined with a reversal of the string’s orientation, which the charge-cancellation conditions require; the usual setting for type IIB flux vacua (a Calabi–Yau space further divided by a reflection, as charge cancellation requires), and it starts from a flux vacuum at which the value of the superpotential, written $W_0$, is very small. Only then can a weak nonperturbative effect fix the overall size afterwards, at a volume large enough to trust the approximations. In 2019 Demirtas, Kim, McAllister and Moritz (DKMM) supplied the benchmark example, with $|W_0|=2.037\times10^{-8}$: small integer fluxes make $W$ vanish identically in perturbation theory, and two competing instantona correction invisible at every order of perturbation theory and exponentially small; here each comes from a string worldsheet wrapping a curve in the geometry corrections leave an exponentially small remainder. Recomputations in 2021 by Broeckel, Cicoli, Maharana, Singh and Sinha and by Carta, Mininno and Shukla (CMS) found $2.048\times10^{-8}$ and $2.0482\times10^{-8}$. All three were floating-point computations without error bounds, and the half-percent discrepancy had not been explained in print.

The exact computation begins by proving that DKMM’s critical point exists. The periods are continued in ball arithmetic from a reference point where their series converge (large complex structure) out to the vacuum. The Krawczyk test on the critical-point equations in six real unknowns succeeds on a box of radius $10^{-10}$, so that box holds exactly one critical point, and six further contractions shrink it to radius about $5\times10^{-149}$. With every instanton degree included through the Picard–Fuchs equations, the result is

$$\begin{aligned}|W_0|_{\rm vac}&=2.037106093\ldots\times10^{-8}\;\pm\;4.4\times10^{-148}\,,\\ \tau_{\rm vac}&=i\cdot 6.855457256\ldots\;\pm\;6.8\times10^{-149}\,.\end{aligned}$$

The first line is the superpotential at the vacuum in reduced Planck units, normalized as in DKMM, with a proven radius, so about 140 digits are guaranteed. The second is the axio-dilatonthe complex scalar $\tau=C_0+i/g_s$ of type IIB string theory, combining an axion with the dilaton, whose expectation value sets the string coupling $g_s$ $\tau$, the complex field whose imaginary part is the inverse string coupling, giving $g_s=0.14587$. Both take DKMM’s integer fluxes and quantization convention as given.

Three rows of marks over a horizontal axis labeled absolute value of W0 in units of 10 to the minus 8 Planck masses cubed, from 2.030 to 2.065. Top row, printed values: a thin bar at 2.037 labeled DKMM 2.037 inside a light gray band, and a thicker bar near 2.048 labeled Broeckel 2.048 and CMS 2.0482 inside a second gray band. Middle row, one code, one toggle (this paper): a filled circle labeled V1: xi included under the DKMM band, an open square labeled V2: xi dropped under the Broeckel/CMS band, and an open triangle near 2.0595 labeled V3: wrong-sign chi (matches nothing). Bottom row, certified ball (this paper): a violet star inside the DKMM band labeled 2.037106093...

The three published values of $|W_0|$ (units of $10^{-8}$) and the proven value. Top row: DKMM’s $2.037$ and the later $2.048$ and $2.0482$, rounding intervals shaded; middle row: one floating-point code run with the $\zeta(3)\chi$ term kept (V1, filled circle), dropped (V2, open square) or given the wrong sign (V3, open triangle), landing on DKMM’s digits, on the two later values, and on nothing published; bottom row: the proven value (violet star), radius $4.4\times10^{-148}$, inside DKMM’s rounding interval. (Redrawn from Figure 2 of the paper.)

The two 2021 papers both state that they drop one constant term, proportional to $\zeta(3)\chi$ with $\chi$ the Euler number of the geometry, from the prepotentialthe holomorphic function of the complex-structure moduli from which the periods near large complex structure are generated by differentiation; its polynomial part carries a constant proportional to $\zeta(3)$ times the Euler number (the function from which the periods are generated); dropping it shifts $|W_0|$ by $0.544\%$, the whole gap. All three computations are correct in their own conventions, and all four of DKMM’s digits are right. A separate exact check concerns the thirty candidate de Sitter vacua (positive cosmological constant) of McAllister, Moritz, Nally and Schachner (2024). A certain rational invariant of their recorded flux integers is nonzero for all thirty, so none is perturbatively flat in DKMM’s sense ($W$ vanishing identically before instanton corrections), as expected from their different construction; the check says nothing about whether any of them is a vacuum.

The paper

Supplementary material

References

S. Gukov, C. Vafa and E. Witten, CFT’s from Calabi-Yau four-folds, Nucl. Phys. B 584 (2000) 69the flux superpotential $W$ whose critical points are the candidate vacua
I. Bena, J. Blåbäck, M. Graña and S. Lüst, The tadpole problem, JHEP 11 (2021) 223the Tadpole Conjecture, with the K3×K3 search that reached charge 25
S. Lüst and M. Wiesner, The tadpole conjecture in the interior of moduli space, JHEP 12 (2023) 029stabilization on the fixed locus of a discrete symmetry, as at the charge-22 vacuum
R. Krawczyk, Newton-Algorithmen zur Bestimmung von Nullstellen mit Fehlerschranken, Computing 4 (1969) 187the interval test that proves a box contains exactly one zero
H. Cohn and N. Elkies, New upper bounds on sphere packings I, Ann. of Math. 157 (2003) 689the packing bound that removes 368,068 candidates at once
H.-V. Niemeier, Definite quadratische Formen der Dimension 24 und Diskriminante 1, J. Number Theory 5 (1973) 142the 24-dimensional even unimodular lattices and their root systems, behind Lemma 3.3
S. Kondō, Automorphisms of algebraic K3 surfaces which act trivially on Picard groups, J. Math. Soc. Japan 44 (1992) 75the K3 surface with an order-66 automorphism, matched to the lattice of the charge-22 flux
G. Höhn and G. Mason, The 290 fixed-point sublattices of the Leech lattice, J. Algebra 448 (2016) 618the table of Leech-lattice sublattices with which three of the seven further root-free lattices are identified
K. Hulek and H. Verrill, On modularity of rigid and nonrigid Calabi-Yau varieties associated to the root lattice $A_4$, Nagoya Math. J. 179 (2005) 103the construction of the fourfold family of Section 4
H. A. Verrill, Sums of squares of binomial coefficients, with applications to Picard-Fuchs equations, arXiv:math/0407327 (2004)the theorem that the fifth-order operator annihilates the fundamental period
H. Jockers, S. Kotlewski and P. Kuusela, Modular Calabi-Yau fourfolds and connections to M-theory fluxes, JHEP 12 (2024) 052the Hulek–Verrill flux frame and periods; hypothesis (O) for the other four periods
J. Dücker, A. Klemm and J. F. Piribauer, Calabi-Yau period geometry and restricted moduli in type II compactifications, JHEP 07 (2025) 225the unit-charge solution at the conifold point $\varphi=1/36$
S. Kachru, R. Kallosh, A. Linde and S. P. Trivedi, De Sitter vacua in string theory, Phys. Rev. D 68 (2003) 046005the KKLT scenario, which needs a very small flux superpotential
M. Demirtas, M. Kim, L. McAllister and J. Moritz, Vacua with small flux superpotential, Phys. Rev. Lett. 124 (2020) 211603the benchmark vacuum with $|W_0|=2.037\times10^{-8}$
I. Broeckel, M. Cicoli, A. Maharana, K. Singh and K. Sinha, On the search for low $W_0$, Fortsch. Phys. 70 (2022) 2200002the recomputation that found $2.048\times10^{-8}$
F. Carta, A. Mininno and P. Shukla, Systematics of perturbatively flat flux vacua, JHEP 02 (2022) 205the recomputation that found $2.0482\times10^{-8}$
L. McAllister, J. Moritz, R. Nally and A. Schachner, Candidate de Sitter vacua, Phys. Rev. D 111 (2025) 086015the thirty de Sitter candidates whose recorded flux data the paper checks

Sibling pages under String theory treat the Grassmannian string integral and modular graph functions.

← back to the web summaries